Is it just me, or is the segway scooter as completely irrelevant as the day it first burst upon the scene oh so many years ago? Why does anyone bother to cover this ridiculous nonsense?
I think the new models sound a lot more promising than the old ones, and I reckon many people share that opinion.
The segway is a great concept but the previous models just weren't convenient enough for common use; the new ones might be, and while still pricey, that may make them a lot more popular. Especially with the anti-theft stuff added to it, which will remove a lot of worries for potential buyers.
The new models sound alot more promising than what? Two over-engineered wheels that do what you normally have to walk to do? If I want two wheels to get me somewhere, I get on a bike, not something that goes slower than I do at a walk.
No offense to you Faruk, but the segway scooter is the worst concept to come along in a long time, and they are still over priced for something that carries you around at slower than walking speed. And for the record, anti-theft devices, like the RFID based ones they put in cars nowadays, have been hacked by car theives. You'd be better off with a high end u-lock. The only people who will tell you otherwise are those who work for insurance or car companies.
Where did you get the "slower than walking speed" bit? Who can walk 12 MPH? Average walking speed is around 4 MPH. Many runners train to achieve a 4 minute mile, which is 15 MPH.
John,
First, like "someone" already pointed out they're a good deal faster than walking speed; they approach casual biking speed, but are a hell of a lot more convenient for certain purposes (and locations where a bike is terribly inconvenient if not downright impossible).
Second, I agree that they're pricey but that's generally always the case with niche-area new technology. The fully hydrogen-powered car isn't exactly cheap either ($5M) but that doesn't make it a crap product.
Third, nowhere is it said that this InfoKey uses RFID, and more importantly, how easy is it for someone to hack a segway system that starts sounding a loud alarm the moment you tinker with or even touch it? I haven't heard of any hackers able to make remote controls that override all currently available methods of security, and "for the record", maybe you could point me to any evidence that the remote car lock security systems implemented in millions of cars today are so easily hacked? Not talking about RFID ones, I'm talking about the ones we've been using for years now.
Yes, everything can be hacked. That doesn't mean it's easy or quick, and if you're leaving your segway out for y'know, two minutes while you walk into a store, you can be fairly certain at least that no hacker will sit down next to it for a while to hack around the security system and take off with it.
Besides that, it would be a wise move on their account if they added a PIN-code lock to the segway's motor interface, so that the thing is safe even if the InfoKeys get duplicated by hackers.
Though the InfoKeys are not RFID, I worry that they won't do much good in laerting you about Segway theft. From the website, I gather that they're actually Bluetooth-based. Bluetooth 2.0+EDR has a maximum range of 100 feet, and reliable maximum range of 30 unobstructed feet.
This would pose a bit of a problem if, say, you're in a lecture on the fourth floor while your Segway is chained to a bike post outside.
Since the day the Original Segway came out, I'd been wondering how strange (and rather half-assed) it was to seamlessly control throttle and yet have to twist a handle to steer.
Finally, the Segway has become what it should have been all along.
Now, if only the new ones would drop to under $1500, I just might get one.
Have you ever been on one? It takes a good 10-15 minutes to get the hang of it, but once you do it is amazing how natural it is. It really does feel like an extension of yourself.
Frankly, I've never been on one, and I'm sure that the current experience is already pretty fantastically intuitive. I actually planned on renting a Segway for a few hours over the summer with a friend. We'd each mount a Segway, hold a giant swimming-pool foam noodle, and Segway-joust. But, internships got in the way of that.
Oh well. When I have enough money to burn, I'll get one.
Have you ever been on one? It takes a good 10-15 minutes to get the hang of it, but once you do it is amazing how natural it is. It really does feel like an extension of yourself.
A guy at work purchased one and let me take it for a spin. It took maybe 3 minutes to completely master it, and your observation about it being an extension of one's self is pretty dead on.
Unfortunately I can't see it being a viable alternatiove to the bicycle because of its cost ($5k range), its range (8-10 miles), and its speed (12 MPH top speed). It certainly is a fun toy, though.
- J
Unfortunately I can't see it being a viable alternatiove to the bicycle because of its cost ($5k range), its range (8-10 miles), and its speed (12 MPH top speed). It certainly is a fun toy, though.
I see price and storage as bigger problems than range or speed. I could see using one to run to the library, post office, etc., but I would not want to leave a $5k segway in a bike rack. Chances are good that I would be walking home.
There are commercial applications that make sense, which seems to be their primary market.
The problem with Segways IMO has always been the fact that you look like a grade A dork while riding one. Not even Steve McQueen could ride one and still look cool. This on the other hand, looks pretty dang cool.
Ha! That thing makes it look like you're riding on a very strong dog or a small Flintstones-like dinosaur.
That, and it's basically a mini-quad, so I'll admit that it looks pretty cool.
I hate Segways. From the first secretive launch and outrageous claims (before they were even unveiled), it was an obvious play to status-conscious-deprived people with too much money. And they look ridiculous. I'd like to see them go out of business.
Hehe, I definitely remember the pseudo-hush-hush surrounding "Ginger" and "It." I know I was disappointedwhen it came out. I just thought: "Wow. That's an amazing engineered... scooter."
I agree. The Segway is now, and always has been, utterly ridiculous. Not only is it impossible NOT to look like a smug jackass riding one... Not only are they cumbersome, annoying hazards on public walkways... Not only are they an overly complex technological answer to a questlon nobody asked... But a two-wheeled personal transport existed long before the Segway's inventor was even born. This miracle device is called the BICYCLE. It's cheaper, simpler, greener, more portable and more versatile than this Segway contraption, by far. Oh - and it has the added benefit of promoting fitness and fighting obesity.
The Segway can eat me.
In Soviet Russia, Segway ride YOU!
There are only two times that I have seen Segways in use. The first is as a way for police to get around the airport quicker. The second is what I was most impressed with. It's a great transportation method for people who have problems walking due to physical disability.
It's not just an overpriced geek gadget that tech nerds ride. Keep in mind that some people have come to depend on Segways as a very reliable tool in helping them get around.
To add to the 'bloated american' image, tour groups have Americans overseas catapulting their bloated carcasses to tour destinations atop segways. How that must add to our cachet.
That is why Segway platforms are built to be able to withstand the weight of a GMC Suburban, not to be confused (for now), with a suburbanite.
I have to agree with Mark's last statement in the 1st paragraph--
The fact is, about 75% of America could stand to walk/jog/run/hop/skip/pedal a LOT more.
Now I'm not saying that if Segway went out of business, it would make the nation more fit; but it wouldn't promote people riding EVERYWHERE they go.
I'm a systems manager at an IT company, and we do a LOT of walking. Last year, we kept track of how much we walked (sprinted sometimes) and averaged about 3.5 miles a day just running around to work on servers or workstations or whatever. I might be a little more tired at the end of the day than if I had a Segway to ride all day, but it certainly helps me burn off the Whoppers and tacos.
Walk, folks; it won't kill you.
With all the hype about how radical this invention was, and the subsequent let-down at the unveiling, it was suggested that what was released wasn't the real "it", but merely a step to the final product: the actual Segway would be a hovercraft of some kind.
Now that would be cool.
Too bad it appears to have been fantasy dreaming. I can't wait to live in a Star Wars universe, sans evil bad guys.
unless the hovering segway is tehtered, you're opening a whole shebang of liability suits-
HEY, she flew into my store window!
Yikes, I don't feel so good (Jerry Lewis voice)... with the barfing and the OY what was that?!
tehtered = tethered
On a technical level, I wonder what kind of resistance curve the pivoting shaft has. I'm assuming that it needs to self-right, but hopefully the resistance will be smooth and not rubbery.
They could halve the price of this thing if they just added a small wheel up front, or in the back.... They are just trying to sell technology because it will raise profits. These things are pointless.
I've seen one use: On the sitcom Freddie, they had a short skit with waiters on segways. They called them segwaiters. [sarcastic laugh here]
All you party poopers make me sad. Yes, it's overpriced. Yes, in most cases it is impractical. But dagnammit, I want one. If only for the slightly surreal experience of moving around on a gyroscoped two-wheeler that would make me feel like what it would be if we had wheels instead of legs.
I want one to. If I had the money to just throw away, I would probably buy one just to treat my friends to rides.
You're in Easy Mode. If you prefer, you can use XHTML Mode instead. |