SDEROT — From the solemnity of a Holocaust museum to a dusty village battered by Hamas rockets, Democratic presidential contender Barack Obama on Wednesday professed "an unshakable commitment to the security" of Israel, whether the threat comes from terrorists, Iran or elsewhere.
"The way you know where somebody's going is where have they been. And I've been with Israel for many, many years now," he said on a day that bore striking similarities to campaigning in the United States.
In his public remarks, Obama sidestepped a question of whether he would condone an Israeli attack to prevent Iran from obtaining a nuclear weapon. But he said he was confident that in several private meetings he had not left Israeli politicians with the impression that, if elected president, he would be "pressuring them to accept any kinds of concessions that would put their security at stake."
Obama packed more than a half-dozen meetings, a stop at the Yad Vashem Holocaust memorial, a helicopter tour of the country and a visit to a house hit by Hamas rockets into his only full day in Israel during his trip to the Middle East and Europe.
He also rode past an Israeli checkpoint into Ramallah on the West Bank, where he assured Palestinian President Mahmoud Abbas of his support for a two-state resolution of the region's long animosities. Later, entering a session with Israeli Prime Minister Ehud Olmert, Obama said his talks with Abbas indicated "there's a strong sense of progress being made" toward peace. Olmert nodded and said, "Indeed."
Before dawn Thursday in Jerusalem, paid a predawn visit to the holiest place in Judaism, bowing his head in prayer at the Western Wall and pushing a small note into a crevice in the ancient wall, a custom that is observed by many.
Obama's major focus was clearly reassuring Israelis — and by extension millions of Jewish voters in the United States — of his commitment to the survival of the Jewish state. He leads his Republican rival, Sen. John McCain of Arizona, among Jewish voters, but his support falls short of what Democrat John Kerry drew four years ago.
Obama said Israelis could be certain of his commitment to Israel's security by looking at "my deeds."
"Just this past week, we passed out of the U.S. Senate Banking Committee, which is my committee, a bill to call for divestment from Iran, as a way of ratcheting up the pressure to ensure that they don't obtain a nuclear weapon," he said.
However, Obama does not serve on the banking committee, and McCain's campaign seized on the mistake.
"Not only is it not his committee, but he's not even on the committee, he didn't vote on the bill, and he had nothing to do with its passage," McCain spokesman Tucker Bounds said in a statement issued Wednesday.
Obama's trip is financed by his presidential campaign, and he flew to Israel from Jordan on Tuesday night about his chartered Boeing 757 emblazoned with his trademark slogan, "Change We Can Believe In."
If his campaign aides were looking for memorable images during the day, they got them, from Obama donning a skullcap at the Holocaust memorial, to President Shimon Peres saying, "God Bless You" outside his official residence, to a stop at a house under reconstruction in Sderot where he saw firsthand the destruction caused by Hamas rockets.
"People are committed," he said, making a fist and thumping his chest three times.
Shielded by intense U.S. and Israeli security, he then traveled a short distance to the local police station. There, Defense Minister Ehud Barak, Foreign Minister Tzipi Livni and local officials showed him racks filled with debris from Hamas rockets that have landed in Sderot in the past seven years. In 2005 Israel withdrew from the Gaza Strip a mile away.
The same racks formed a made-for-television backdrop for a news conference attended not only by U.S. reporters, but also Israelis whose satellite trucks jammed the parking lot across the street.
Eli Moyal, the local mayor, gave Obama a souvenir T-shirt — merely the latest he has received since he began running for president — and the senator also came away with a gift of a piece of rocket as artwork, attached to a wooden plaque.
Gaza Hamas official Fawzi Barhoum had a less-favorable response to Obama's visit to Sderot:
"Hamas considers the remarks of the Democratic candidate today to be part of the American policy of bias towards Israel and giving legitimacy to Israeli crimes against our people. His remarks today give cover for the occupation's nonstop crimes against our people."
The subject of Tehran's presumed drive to gain a nuclear weapon — and the threat that would pose to Israel — was a recurrent theme throughout the day.
The American presidential candidate said, "Iranians need to understand that whether it's the Bush administration or an Obama administration, that this is a paramount concern to the United States."
He said he favors both "big sticks and carrots" to persuade Iranians to switch course.
"What I have also said, though, is that I will take no options off the table in dealing with this potential Iranian threat. And understand part of my reasoning here.
"A nuclear Iran would be a game-changing situation, not just in the Middle East but around the world. Whatever remains of our nuclear nonproliferation framework, I think, would begin to disintegrate. You would have countries in the Middle East who would see the potential need to also obtain nuclear weapons."
At his news conference, Obama brushed aside a question of whether he had backed off his statement this spring that Jerusalem should be the undivided capital of Israel. Palestinians also lay claim to the city as the capital for any state they establish as the result of peace talks, and the two sides have agreed that the final decision is to be negotiated.
Criticized by Abbas after he made that comment, Obama subsequently amended it. "Well, obviously, it's going to be up to the parties to negotiate a range of these issues. And Jerusalem will be part of those negotiations," he said. He added that "as a practical matter, it would be very difficult to execute" a division of the city.
Abbas issued a statement saying he and Obama had not discussed the issue in their hour together.
Asked by an Israeli reporter about the matter, Obama said, "I continued to say that Jerusalem will be the capital of Israel. And I have said that before and I will say it again. And I also have said that it is important that we don't simply slice the city in half. But I've also said that that's a final status issue."
Obama departs on Thursday for Germany, where he is scheduled to deliver an outdoor speech before a large crowd. He also has stops planned for France and England before flying back to the United States on Saturday.
___
Associated Press writers Matti Friedman, Laurie Copans and Ian Deitch contributed to this story.
"It is because if we show ourselves willing to talk and to offer carrots and sticks in order to deal with these pressing problems, and if Iran then rejects any overtures of that sort, it puts us in a stronger position to mobilize the international community to ratchet up the pressure on Iran."
I would whole-heartedly agree with this sentiment if I felt that the international community would be willing, under any circumstances, to ratchet up the pressure in any meaningful way.
It can't hurt to try and show we're willing to try to discuss things. Instead of just remaking Beach Boy songs into talking about bombing them.
There is a reason Captain America always did the talking, not Incredible Hulk.
HULK SMASH.
I think the international community would be much more willing to get behind Obama's policies, seeing as how they are more commonsensical, as opposed to Bush.
We should not be offering the security of an apartheid state, any more than when Reagan supported apartheid in South Africa, and Dick Cheney was the last person to agree to release Mandela, calling him a terrorist.
The corporate media including its Zionist apologists, nationalists, neocon cheerleaders refuse to look at the evidence:
'The presidential campaigns of Democrats and Republicans are no more about placing issues before the US public than competing commercials for new cars or bottled water are about the facts. Brought to us by the same corporate marketers that sell us lifestyles and beer, mainstream presidential campaigns aim to establish and exploit visceral, fact-proof loyalties to the brand of a party or candidate. The fact-proof nature of the Obama brand, and the lengths corporate media go to protect it were on prominent display during the candidate's brief visit to Israel Palestine this week.
Barack Obama's smiling brown face and Kansas-Kenya parentage are key elements in the Obama brand, that hazy image of progressive, post-racial transformation at home and abroad which lie at the heart of his appeal. At the same time, Barack Obama is committed to preserving what he calls Israel's "identity as a Jewish state", the polite term for what much of the rest of the world recognizes as an apartheid state.'
http://www.commondreams.org/archive/2008/07/23/10537/ and
http://www.zmag.org/znet/viewArticle/18247
Obama is echoing Dubya about Iran. Most amusing.
Wow. He's just looking better and better.
Why wouldn't we want to talk to the Iranians? We talked with the Russian didn't we? Maybe we could buy some of the Iranian oil and import Cuban ethanol while were at it.
People are still attacking this idea? Who is he defending it from? Hillary? Everyone else seems to have seen the light.
Hmmm... Must be more of that "Change you can count on".
Okay, seriously, I'm glad to see he's refined his position on this issue. I think he would have served himself better to admit that under more advice, he's given better consideration for how to diplomatically handle regimes such as Iran, Venezuela, and North Korea. I think this shows a maturing in his policy stances and makes me feel more comfortable about the posibility of him being elected.
But what I also said was that there is a difference between meeting without preconditions and meeting without preparation."
Yes obama ---there is a difference---you told us you'd meet without "preconditions," not without "preparation".......and
"That's an issue that has to be dealt with the parties involved, the Palestinians and the Israelis, and it is not the job of the United States to dictate the form in which that will take, but rather to support the efforts that are being made right now to resolve these very difficult issues that have a long history,"
I see Obama has learned the proper response to this Jerusalem question post his pandering to the jewish vote at AIPAC.....oh, as I recall that time it was a problem with his "syntax"......yeah, sure.
Not able to come up with anything substantive I see. Just curious, but what are you going to do come November when your GOP isn't in control of anything? Oh right, whine about everything, just like Republicans do now.
Lisa, weren't you the one bemoaning the lack of focus on substance yesterday?
BTW, what has your guy McCain done lately to show he'd be a good president?
gar, please show me where my grammar is lacking, or otherwise insufficient.
Just curious, but what are you going to do come November when your GOP isn't in control of anything?
BAJunkie-6.1---oh, don't worry bout me....it will be a very nice "change" (no pun intended) to be able to watch the dems get blamed for EVERYTHING that goes wrong with the world.....
it will be a very nice "change" (no pun intended) to be able to watch the dems get blamed for EVERYTHING that goes wrong with the world.....
Ugh. How disgusting. Is pointing fingers and saying "haha I told you so" the only thing that will make you happy? If so, what a SAD existence you have.
You're right, Obama has gotten wise to the diplomatic way of responding to the Israeli/Palestinian question. I don't see the need, however, for making this a Republican vs. Democrat hate session.
Barack Hussein Obama's "CARROT" to Ahmadinejad of Iran: Surrendering Iraq to Iran to create a "SHIA EMPIRE", and to teach "DOUBLE-TALK"
Barack Hussein Obama's "STICK" to Ahmadinejad: Withhold Funding for "Re-enactment of Holocaust in Tehran"
Well, at least they're starting to put 'Dumb' in their names so we can easily distinguish them now.
Merriam Webster's definition of Commonsensical I don't need to pretend. If you were educated enough to type commonsensical into google, you would find 175,000 hits. But I've provided the link for you, because I don't want to be rude while proving you wrong. Also, we don't really live in a democracy, it's a republic. In this republic, votes don't necessarily count the same. Why, you ask? Because of the electoral college. So my vote might be worth just a little more than yours, and conversely, yours could be worth a little more than mine, depending on the location where we each reside. But what do I know, I'm only pretending to be educated.
commonsensical = pragmatic. That wasn't very hard to figure out.
Iran will invade Israel. period. Ezekiel 38
Invaders destroyed. Ezekial 39
Right, then jeebus will come down on a cloud and save us all, because that's what this book of mythology says. Give me a break.
Last I checked, Iran was more East of Israel then "far North." But that tale could hold merit... if you choose to read it that way.
Careful. Zeus is going to throw a lightening bolt at you.
ESPN magazine pg. 12
miss dev read it yourself...it will happen. Russia, Persia. It's going to be bad. Miss dev I was in Israel in 77 our Muslim guide was very adamant at that time....we're not finished until Israel is in the sea. Look at a map....compared to the land mass of Iran, Iraq, Saudia Arabia, Syria...Israel is a dot on the map. Why destroy this little bit of land?
And junkie...no myth. your country was founded on the judeo-christian ethics. You are so blessed and don't even know it, move to saudia arabia and see how many freedoms you have in an Islamic country. The bible is true.
your country was founded on the judeo-christian ethics
Ethics, not the book itself.
Also, let's not forget the incredible influence of the polytheistic Greeks. Thank you, Athens, for being such an impressive model of a successful democratic society.
This fight has already gone on for thousands of years and yet there has been no apocalypse.
@koobee - I have read it, otherwise I wouldn't quote from it. Also, you said "Iran will invade Israel. period." Not "Iran or Russia will invade Israel. period." And since when was Iran part of Russia? Or did you not know that Persia was the previous name for Iran, and not a separate country?
Look at a map....compared to the land mass of Iran, Iraq, Saudia Arabia, Syria...Israel is a dot on the map.
I have. That's how I know that Iran is not to the "far north" of Israel. Or are you saying that your Holy Book is not entirely correct about that statement?
Hey Miss Dev...I know Persia was the previous name of Iran. Ezekial says Persia because that was the name at that time. When I said "Iran will invade Israel. Period. I was just saying Iran is a definite. THis does not invalidate other countries mentioned in Ezekial also will invading Israel. Cush, Put,Gomer, Beth-togarmah, Gog. I'm reading a book right now which identifies these ancient lands in today's geography.
My bottom line is...there's going to be trouble, big trouble. And no political carrots are going to stop it from happening.
"Iran will invade Israel. period. Ezekiel 38/Invaders destroyed. Ezekial 39"
Does this mean we can stop sending them billions of tax dollars a year?
"Hamas considers the remarks of the Democratic candidate today to be part of the American policy of bias towards Israel and giving legitimacy to Israeli crimes against our people. His remarks today give cover for the occupation's nonstop crimes against our people."
::sigh:: No one can ever get on their good side.
I wonder what Obama really plans to do with this if he's elected. A marshmallow roast around a campfire? A therapy session for the leaders of all sides with Dr. Phil? Exactly how is he going to deal with Hamas? A firm hand or a gentle one?
I'd like a more definitive answer as to exactly what Obama plans to do to make peace in the region rather than just hearing him say that "this is a paramount concern to the United States."
He prefers Oprah . Doctor Phil would figure him out and spoil his illusion. He likes kissy face better
Aren't you the person that complained about BA pointing out someone had "Dumb" in their name?
It should not be our place to protect Israel , after all they have been in war after war for how many years why should we allow them to take us down with them. This country has nothing to bring to our table, and just looking for hand outs.
You're in Easy Mode. If you prefer, you can use XHTML Mode instead. |