After nearly two weeks on the market, the much-anticipated BlackBerry Storm has lived up to its name, with longtime BlackBerry loyalists frustrated by the smartphone's bugginess, sluggishness and user unfriendliness with its three touchscreen keyboards.
Their rants are shared at several phone and BlackBerry-related Web sites, including Research In Motion's own community support forums, where customers are finding empathy but little in the way of answers from the company that makes the legendary line of business-class phones equipped with e-mail and Web browsing.
"Having used many other Research In Motion devices, I can't remember a device being released with so many bugs," said Allen Nogee, In-Stat Research's principal analyst for wireless technology and infrastructure.
The Storm has been the buzz of the BlackBerry world for much of the year. Its release date was pushed back at least once, from September to November. Perhaps it should have been pushed back more.
"There is no doubt that this device was rushed to market to make the Christmas selling season," said Nogee. "Unfortunately, the decision was made to ship this device with bugs and fix them later, rather than to fix them first, and then sell the device."
That may be so. There are Web postings about software fixes that are on the way to deal with both the Storm's hardware and its operating system.
Little word from RIM
So far, RIM has not commented on the problems of its first all-touchscreen BlackBerry, considered a strong competitor to Apple's touchscreen iPhone.
Verizon Wireless, the exclusive carrier of the device in the United States, has said little, except how well sales have gone. The company, like most, doesn't publicly share sales figures.
When the Storm was released Nov. 21, there were lines of customers outside many Verizon Wireless stores around the country, with the same kind of excitement consumers felt about the iPhone's release.
"This is the fastest-selling device we've had to date," said Nancy Starker, a Verizon Wireless spokeswoman.
She referred questions about the phone's performance to RIM, but did say, "As with any phone, there are constant tweaks that are made and pushed to the phone" via the carrier's wireless network.
On its Web site yesterday, Verizon Wireless said it will be Dec. 15 before new Storms are available to be shipped. Some speculate that the delay is to give RIM time to make the needed software and firmware updates to the phone.
The Storm costs $199.99 after committing to a two-year contract with Verizon Wireless and mailing in a $50 rebate.
Keyboard difficulties
Among the problems users report is difficulty with the Storm’s three touchscreen keyboards. In vertical, or portrait mode, there are two choices: RIM's SureType keyboard, with two letters to a key, or a "multi-tap" keyboard that resembles a dial pad. In horizontal, or landscape, mode, there's a QWERTY keyboard, with one character per key.
Some users feel the keys on all three are too small to get accurate results from touch entry.
When I reviewed the Storm two weeks ago, I'd had it in my possession for less than a day. I felt then, as I do now, that there is a lot to like about it, including its video camera, and the ability to text or e-mail video files, built-in voice-activated dialing — all features lacking in the iPhone.
I wasn't crazy about the keyboards, but didn't know if it was a matter of getting used to them.
Two weeks later, I still like the phone, but am not liking the drudgery involved in tapping out e-mails.
There have also been complaints about slow and laggy performance by the device’s accelerometer, a motion sensor that shifts the screen from vertical to horizontal position.
I find this to be the case — except when I don't want it to shift position. Then, for some bizarre reason, it's like an exorcist has taken over the phone and it shifts when it wants to. That's annoying.
All in all, the phone's performance has been uneven so far, something that seems unthinkable for a BlackBerry.
The Storm uses a “clickable” touchscreen that has received praise for its tactile feedback.
“I really like the touch/click system when it comes to navigating the Storm’s user interface or Web pages,” said Avi Greengart, Current Analysis’ research director for mobile devices.
“However, when applied to the keyboard, the results have been less than ideal so far.”
The Storm, he said, “is somewhat sluggish, and I have found that you can type quickly or accurately, but not both.”
His experience has been that of many others, as well. And among the most vocal are BlackBerry fans, as passionate about their devices as iPhone owners are about theirs.
“This is my Blackberry. There are many like it but this one is mine,” says one devoted user’s tag line on CrackBerry.com “My Blackberry is my best friend. It is my life. I must master it as I must master my life. Without me, my Blackberry is useless. Without my Blackberry I am useless.”
Startling change for BlackBerry alum
What may make the Storm’s problems seem even worse is that many of its owners are longtime BlackBerry customers who are used to having not just a good physical keyboard, but one that is considered the best in the smartphone industry.
And for those trying the Storm as their first BlackBerry, they’re seeing a product that, right now, does not live up to the reputations of its predecessors.
Storm users report various other issues, including a shutter delay with the camera (more so than most cell phone cameras), problems with the media player crashing and general bugginess with the screen and menu entries.
None of this comes at a good time, especially with the economy. RIM has been the smartphone leader in the business world, but the consumer market is a different animal, with more competitors.
Head-to-head battle
Apple and RIM have been battling head-to-head in the smartphone arena, with the iPhone adding features that appeal to the business set, and several BlackBerry models, including the Storm, aiming to have more consumer appeal.
In recent months, RIM released two other models aimed at freshening their lineup and taking on the iPhone.
The BlackBerry Bold, with a physical keyboard, costs $299.99 after a rebate and with a two-year contract through AT&T, the exclusive provider of the Bold in the United States. The BlackBerry Pearl Flip, a first-time clamshell phone by RIM, is offered by T-Mobile and costs $150 after a rebate and committing to a two-year contract.
But it is the Storm that many had been eagerly anticipating.
“If I am going to buy something, I expect it to work,” wrote one Storm user on CrackBerry.com. “I don't think I should have to buy something to wait for a software upgrade to get it to work correctly.”
“I think dumping an unfinished, buggy device on people was pretty shameful and shoddy,” said another.
“Folks need to take a chill pill,” wrote one Storm user on CrackBerry.com. “Are there issues? Sure there are. Would it be nice if Verizon/RIM gave us some straight answers? Yup. But it does work and I'm 150 percent sure that once the updates are delivered the Storm will be what it should have been from the start.”
Nogee, the In-Stat wireless analyst, said he, too, believes “in time, the bugs will be worked out, and the phone will be a good one. But for those plopping down their $200 and signing up for a rather expensive contract, it’s not a very friendly welcome.”
Software updates are on their way that address these and other issues. Please be patient.
I installed the .75 update the other day. Acceleromator and camera delays have been fixed. The device runs much smoother. As far as the keyboard....it takes practice, but you get the hang of it. On the QWERTY keyboard draw an imaginary line that sperates the t-y, g-h, and v-b and don't cross over it with your thumbs. You will cut down on your mistakes that way. I bought the device on Nov. 21st and have really enjoyed it. Great device and the software updates will only make it better
A halfway decent camera on a phone is important to me, as I need to take at least somewhat detailed shots to text/email back to my office while on a site. My old Flipshot had an excellent camera, but the regular style keyboard became too much of a pain to text on, so the Storm seemed like the perfect fit. I was ok with the click screen, key sizes, etc... and I could even live with slightly sluggish performance. But my camera was defective right off the bat, taking photos even at full resolution that looked like faded watercolor paintings. The camera controls are poorly designed, and it's FAR slower with shutter lag than any cell camera I've ever seen. Taking it back to my local Verizon store was only more frustrating as you'd have thought I slapped someone's mother for DARING to bring back a Storm (at least the way the employee reacted who handled my return - reluctantly). I couldn't wait for "fixes". I traded it in for a LG Dare and am much happier.
Verizon should be promoting the new Samsung Omnia for Xmas - far better phone, many more features and really slick. It beats the Blackberry and in most cases the Iphone. It is a great phone.
There's a lesson to be learned here - don't buy in the tornado. Technology always require improvement after the first release, so why bother standing in lines for something that will be cheaper, and work better, later on?
The lesson to be learned here is to get an iPhone. Costs the same amount and works perfectly out of the box.
Where is this made? If it is made in China, then anybody who bought these deserves all the problems they have encountered.
Heellooooo, it's the software that's in control. Software for this device is written by teams around the world. The iPhone is made in Taiwan, are you seeing it break? Please get your facts straight.
Truth be told, I had the option of either getting a Blackberry or an iPhone for work. I went with the iPhone. I am glad that I did. One of the best reasons is the fact of the App Store which has brought in some fantastic applications -- especially for finance and medical applications. In my own oppinion, it beats the Blackberry offerings hands down.
I am not a blackberry user and actively dislike the iphone and all that Apple stands for... I tried the storm for about 10min at a verizon store and was completely annoyed with the functionality, sluggishness, and awkwardness of the touch screen and accelerometer. Not ready for prime time.
Should have never been released until the more than obvious bugs were worked out and I am seriously disgusted by Verizon's denial in claiming they have not received many calls on issues with the phone. Ironically on 2 Dec, I was the first to have called for issues both on the customer service line and on the tech support line. Tech support was a little nasty with me on the problems I was claiming to have t with the phone. Truth be told, there was very little interest in what I had to say about it. I told the lady the phone is half baked, and in it's current configuration out of the box is a piece of crapp! She refused to believe me when I explained the light eminating around the edge of the screen and my concerns about any sort of moisture or debris entering through these glaringly large openings in my opinion. Refusing to get me a replacement phone, she demanded that I take it to a Verizon store then let the technician decide if it's a flawed phone. Really? Whatever happened to the "If you're not satisified in 30 days, we'll replace it"?? Anyway, peeved off at Verizon for such shoddy service and then playing the game of "You won't get a replacement until Jan 15th". Hmmmm. Odd, new customers are getting phones by 15 Dec.
Here's the moral of this story... if you bought a buggy defective storm, don't expect any replacement within the Verizon satisfaction guarantee window. They are doing this in order to not show poor sales results for the holidays forcing disatisfied customers to be stuck with the defective product while they push more defective product for holiday sales for newer customers. It really is sickening that Verizon would be behind such antics, but being the victim of poor tech support customer service and being too picky, etc and apparently not telling the truth about what I am having to deal with this device as customer is just in many ways, wrong. Basically Verizon in essence told me that I was full of it.
What would happen if Apple came out with a piece of garbage like this? The true nature of Verizon and RIMM are now obvious and will be their downfall. Guess non of the RIMM programmers are getting a holiday vacation either.
PS: RIMM is doing more for Apple right now than 100's of millions of dollars of ads.
heheh... Broke even before you get it.
Takes b@lls to sell a broken product, and the people who buy it? Hmmmm....
Who would buy a known broken product? I know I would not.
I am so glad I got the iPhone
People are way too willing to be fleeced. If I had bought this buggy phone, I would not be waiting for firmware updates. If you sell me something, it had better work out of the box or you're getting it back and I'm getting a full refund, including the monthly service plan. I make sure of that before I buy anything.
Unfortunately it is becoming all too common for companies to release products before they really work. I'm sure the pressure from Verizon was strong to get this phone out before Christmas, and I'm sure RIM did its very best to fix all the bugs, but in the end its the loyal customer that suffers.
If you buy a defective product, don't just say "oh, they will fix it in time." Instead, return it and tell them you will buy it again once it works. If customers don't stand up to this, guess what? It will happen again and again because manufacturers and operators know they can get away with it. If you return it, your saying that these companies should suffer the financial consequences of their action, and money talks. By returning it, they are taking the financial hit, and guess what? They will be far less inclined to repeating the same behavior in the future.
I agree much with what you say, but the problem is a lot of times even a decive with a few bugs, is better than no device at all. Getting an old device that's be "fixed" can amount to being more costly as well, because then you are essentially buying two devices. One to get while you wait for the one you want to be "fixed" and then the one you want when it is "fixed"
Apple's products have shown perfection so far and have lived up to the name. All these new products coming out are the result of jealousy for Apple's quality. Further more, there has been an increase of iPhone wannabe out in the market, but all have failed because instead of being original they have tried to imitate the iphone. Remember the Instinct from Sprint?
Apple products are far far FAR from perfection. The iPhone is not excused from that either. After 5+ years, I still come accross people who fall victim to faulty batteries in their iPods. You'd think they would have fixed that issue by now.
I don't know but since I switched to apple I haven't got any more problems, no crashes, etc. Sure that there is a down side for everything, I should have never utilized the word "perfection", nonetheless, the new revolution of iphones wannabe should come up with something better instead of imitating the iphone (which I don't owe by the way). Apple has come from the bottom and yet their products are more expensive they're, indeed, more reliable that Microsoft. Again, I don't have an iphone, but if I was into that type of gadget I will get one, not the blackberry.
I just wanna know: Who are the geeks who stand in line for hours, to buy a phone? Get an effing life for crying out loud!
There are a lot worst things that people have stood in line for. Tickle Me Elmo anyone?
LOL!!! So true...
Tickle me Elmo, LMAO. That was bad, but tat was for your child, so I can giveyou a little leeway.
The phone? You're a grown ass man sitting outside a cell phone store for a phone....WHEN YOU FRIGGIN HAVE ONE ALREADY!
Or people who sleep outside a mall to buy Madden video games? I love video games, but noone is gonna get me to sleep outside a store for one. It would be one thing if they were giving AWAY money, not a place where you are spending it.
Did people really stood in line for Tickle me Elmo? OMG, where are we as society?
Was all set and ready to go buy The Storm (currently have the LG/Verizon Voyager), until I went into the Verizon store and played with it for about 30 minutes. Found it absolutely impossible to type an accurate email / text message. Because texts and emails are what I mostly use the phone for, I will never buy the Storm, even though I liked all the other features, until they put a usable keyboard similar to the Voyager keyboard !!
Just as well that I have t-mobile-and I am very happy with my best phone ever- the Curve 8320-fantastic keyboard(and I have large fingers) big deal about a touch screen-you can't have everything in this world-my daughter can't wait for me to get my next blackberry with tmobile so she can have my current Curve-she's 13 and smart enough to know a phone that blows away those lame LG EnV and phones of that nature.
You're in Easy Mode. If you prefer, you can use XHTML Mode instead. |