Ex-Bush aides say he never recovered from Katrina

advertisement

WASHINGTON — Hurricane Katrina not only pulverized the Gulf Coast in 2005, it knocked the bully pulpit out from under President George W. Bush, according to two former advisers who spoke candidly about the political impact of the government's poor handling of the natural disaster.

"Katrina to me was the tipping point," said Matthew Dowd, Bush's pollster and chief strategist for the 2004 presidential campaign. "The president broke his bond with the public. Once that bond was broken, he no longer had the capacity to talk to the American public. State of the Union addresses? It didn't matter. Legislative initiatives? It didn't matter. P.R.? It didn't matter. Travel? It didn't matter."

Dan Bartlett, former White House communications director and later counselor to the president, said: "Politically, it was the final nail in the coffin."

Their comments are a part of an oral history of the Bush White House that Vanity Fair magazine compiled for its February issue, which hits newsstands in New York and Los Angeles on Wednesday, and nationally on Jan. 6. Vanity Fair published comments by current and former government officials, foreign ministers, campaign strategists and numerous others on topics that included Iraq, the anthrax attacks, the economy and immigration.

Lawrence Wilkerson, top aide and later chief of staff to former Secretary of State Colin Powell, said that as a new president, Bush was like Alaska Gov. Sarah Palin, the 2008 GOP vice presidential nominee whom critics said lacked knowledge about foreign affairs. When Bush first came into office, he was surrounded by experienced advisers like Vice President Dick Cheney and Powell, who Wilkerson said ended up playing damage control for the president.

"It allowed everybody to believe that this Sarah Palin-like president — because, let's face it, that's what he was — was going to be protected by this national-security elite, tested in the cauldrons of fire," Wilkerson said, adding that he considered Cheney probably the "most astute, bureaucratic entrepreneur" he'd ever met.

"He became vice president well before George Bush picked him," Wilkerson said of Cheney. "And he began to manipulate things from that point on, knowing that he was going to be able to convince this guy to pick him, knowing that he was then going to be able to wade into the vacuums that existed around George Bush — personality vacuum, character vacuum, details vacuum, experience vacuum."

On other topics, David Kuo, who served as deputy director of the White House Office of Faith-Based and Community Initiatives, disputed the idea that the Bush White House was dominated by religious conservatives and catered to the needs of a religious right voting bloc.

"The reality in the White House is — if you look at the most senior staff — you're seeing people who aren't personally religious and have no particular affection for people who are religious-right leaders," Kuo said.

"In the political affairs shop in particular, you saw a lot of people who just rolled their eyes at ... basically every religious-right leader that was out there, because they just found them annoying and insufferable. These guys were pains in the butt who had to be accommodated."

  • 66 Votes
  • Enjoy this article? Help vote it up the 'Vine.

Back To Top

Published to:

What's this?
Who's leading the conversation?
This visualization below allows you to see the impact that each user has on the current conversation. The top row contains the group of users who have had the most impact, the 2nd row the group of users who have had the 2nd most impact (et cetera). Users with similar impact are grouped together, and the average score of the group is shown to the left of the group. The author of the article is also shown on the left, in their corresponding group. Each user's score is based on the number of comments the user has made plus the number of votes their comments have received. The scores are calculated relative one another, so while their absolute value is not particularly important, their relative difference does indicate a larger difference in impact on the conversation.
13

2.9
Jump to discussion page: 1 2 3
{"commentId":4594312,"authorDomain":"CBOB"}

where is our president, ooh he is on vacation, we have a crises and he is cutting logs again, like he did when Ben laden was going to strike inside the us, that is what the pdb he got in Crawford said.

{"commentId":4594312,"threadId":"455900","contentId":"2256373","authorDomain":"CBOB"}
  • 3 votes
Reply#26 - Tue Dec 30, 2008 1:50 AM EST
{"commentId":4594350,"authorDomain":"CBOB"}

Mr president don't leave Crawford, get in bed and pull the covers over your head and hope Miss Rice can put a lid on this crisis until we get someone who can think. Obama and Biden.

{"commentId":4594350,"threadId":"455900","contentId":"2256373","authorDomain":"CBOB"}
  • 3 votes
Reply#27 - Tue Dec 30, 2008 1:56 AM EST
{"commentId":4594456,"authorDomain":"watersportgirl"}

Condi Rice used to be a critical thinking woman of substance, but has been a lame Bush puppet for years.  Don't count on her for anything.

Did you see the way Colin Powell put the tail between his legs and walked out of the administration?  To think a decorated general would do that!  And in his place, Condi Rice, the lame puppet? 

There's more going on than we know.  The books that will be written after this presidency will make for great reading...

{"commentId":4594456,"threadId":"455900","contentId":"2256373","authorDomain":"watersportgirl"}
  • 4 votes
#27.1 - Tue Dec 30, 2008 2:18 AM EST
{"commentId":4607116,"authorDomain":"jhavok"}
jimmy havok-596667Deleted
{"commentId":4607688,"authorDomain":"a0ted"}

I am very impressed with the career of the Dr. Condoleeza Rice.

When she runs for President, my vote will be given without hesitation.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Condoleezza_Rice

{"commentId":4607688,"threadId":"455900","contentId":"2256373","authorDomain":"a0ted"}
  • 1 vote
#27.3 - Tue Dec 30, 2008 10:46 PM EST
{"commentId":4615640,"authorDomain":"Aunk"}

Hetep and Respect determined, The Wicked Witch of the West is part of Bush and the forty thieves. She is just as guilty of treason as the rest of them. In addition, many African Americans also understand that she has committed Cultural Treason by attacking Haiti and removing the democratically elected President.  

She should be tried right next to Bush and put in jail for the rest of her natural life.

{"commentId":4615640,"threadId":"455900","contentId":"2256373","authorDomain":"Aunk"}
  • 4 votes
#27.4 - Wed Dec 31, 2008 3:10 PM EST
{"commentId":4616321,"authorDomain":"Zoilus"}

Aunk, with all respect.

I have known, believed and used this quote in response to many of the comments of blind unwaving devotion form the right towards their god Bush here for years.

a Patriot supports his country all the time, and his government when it deserves it. Samuel Clemens 

And I swear on the Consecution, I hold dear, that if Obama does not hold true to his promises I will quote below, I will be the first to go to Washington.

Bunch reported that Obama said:

"What I would want to do is to have my Justice Department and my Attorney General immediately review the information that's already there and to find out are there inquiries that need to be pursued... 

If crimes have been committed, they should be investigated....

You're also right that I would not want my first term consumed by what was perceived on the part of Republicans as a partisan witch hunt because I think we've got too many problems we've got to solve.

So this is an area where I would want to exercise judgment -- I would want to find out directly from my Attorney General -- having pursued, having looked at what's out there right now -- are there possibilities of genuine crimes as opposed to really bad policies. And I think it's important-- one of the things we've got to figure out in our political culture generally is distinguishing between really dumb policies and policies that rise to the level of criminal activity. You know, I often get questions about impeachment at town hall meetings and I've said that is not something I think would be fruitful to pursue because I think that impeachment is something that should be reserved for exceptional circumstances. Now, if I found out that there were high officials who knowingly, consciously broke existing laws, engaged in cover-ups of those crimes with knowledge forefront, then I think a basic principle of our Constitution is nobody above the law -- and I think that's roughly how I would look at it."

So, I have a wait and see attitude. But all that I see is how Bush seems worried if not scared, and it is more and more obvious with each passing day. It is not a legacy he is trying to establish, but alibis.

{"commentId":4616321,"threadId":"455900","contentId":"2256373","authorDomain":"Zoilus"}
  • 3 votes
#27.5 - Wed Dec 31, 2008 4:02 PM EST
Reply
{"commentId":4594567,"authorDomain":"directories"}

Katrina was Bush's first major failure, and continues to dog him to this day.  It will be a good day when he leaves office.  Then his incompetence will no longer influence the daily lives of Americans.  But it will be a long and hard road to recover from his combined failures.

{"commentId":4594567,"threadId":"455900","contentId":"2256373","authorDomain":"directories"}
  • 2 votes
Reply#28 - Tue Dec 30, 2008 2:46 AM EST
{"commentId":4594596,"authorDomain":"watersportgirl"}

I think Bush's first major failure was getting up in the morning of his inauguration.

Followed by his advocacy of a secret energy policy (those closed door sessions with Cheney).

And then his reaction to 9/11 - both on the day it happened and everyday after that, culminating with sending precious U.S. blood to Iraq.

Add in a host of other items.  The list is endless.  Where do we begin?  But Katrina is not his first.

But I'm with you, vmoptions........it will be a long and hard road to recover from his failures!

{"commentId":4594596,"threadId":"455900","contentId":"2256373","authorDomain":"watersportgirl"}
  • 7 votes
#28.1 - Tue Dec 30, 2008 2:54 AM EST
{"commentId":4594668,"authorDomain":"aine"}
{"commentId":4594668,"threadId":"455900","contentId":"2256373","authorDomain":"aine"}
  • 5 votes
#28.2 - Tue Dec 30, 2008 3:13 AM EST
{"commentId":4594732,"authorDomain":"tyroanee"}

Aine

Love the List:

11. Hurricane Katrina and the drowning of New Orleans

Hurricanes Rita and Katrina, the destruction of New Orleans, FEMA and "Heck of a job, Brownie," lack of preparation, lack of emergency aid, slowness of reconstruction, Bush ignores for days then gives address from Jackson Square in New Orleans promising aid which never comes or much of which goes to politically connected outstate no bid contractors, disparity between response to Louisiana and Republican Trent Lott’s Mississippi; Bush refuses to waive 10% state match for federal funds (waived in many previous disasters) increasing the bureaucratic paperwork, reducing aid to affected areas, and further slowing and complicating rebuilding.

Argh what a slob

we had in a president

{"commentId":4594732,"threadId":"455900","contentId":"2256373","authorDomain":"tyroanee"}
  • 5 votes
#28.3 - Tue Dec 30, 2008 3:38 AM EST
{"commentId":4597576,"authorDomain":"a0ted"}

Interesting list.

From 1/20/09 there will be a new list also. Noblesse oblige, of course.

{"commentId":4597576,"threadId":"455900","contentId":"2256373","authorDomain":"a0ted"}
  • 1 vote
#28.4 - Tue Dec 30, 2008 10:59 AM EST
{"commentId":4604691,"authorDomain":"bigblackguy"}

Hey guy. Its okay if you can't stand Obama. Its people like you who got him elected. Moron.

{"commentId":4604691,"threadId":"455900","contentId":"2256373","authorDomain":"bigblackguy"}
  • 1 vote
#28.5 - Tue Dec 30, 2008 5:42 PM EST
{"commentId":4605587,"authorDomain":"tyroanee"}

bigblackguy

I really truly hope that everyone has compassion for OBAMA... we are going to need all the support we can to alleviate the devastation from the last eight years.

{"commentId":4605587,"threadId":"455900","contentId":"2256373","authorDomain":"tyroanee"}
  • 3 votes
#28.6 - Tue Dec 30, 2008 7:01 PM EST
Reply
{"commentId":4594715,"authorDomain":"CBOB"}

Mr Radmacher, Cheney rolled Mr Bush under the Bush when he gave a interview saying that he did not agree with him on firing Rumsfield, and that we still would have gone to war even if their  were no w. m. d.

{"commentId":4594715,"threadId":"455900","contentId":"2256373","authorDomain":"CBOB"}
  • 2 votes
Reply#29 - Tue Dec 30, 2008 3:34 AM EST
{"commentId":4594858,"authorDomain":"irvingfuror"}

Uh, we did vote for him. Twice. And by "we" I mean not me. As the saying goes, we get the president we deserve.

{"commentId":4594858,"threadId":"455900","contentId":"2256373","authorDomain":"irvingfuror"}
  • 2 votes
Reply#30 - Tue Dec 30, 2008 4:18 AM EST
{"commentId":4595113,"authorDomain":"pakmanjonzun"}

That was the democrats fault for trying to get lieberman in.

We wouldn't expect anything less than bush from the far right, but the far left enabled it.

{"commentId":4595113,"threadId":"455900","contentId":"2256373","authorDomain":"pakmanjonzun"}
  • 1 vote
#30.1 - Tue Dec 30, 2008 6:18 AM EST
{"commentId":4596376,"authorDomain":"yellowknife-street-railway"}

thomrob

That was the democrats fault for trying to get lieberman in.

We wouldn't expect anything less than bush from the far right, but the far left enabled it

Sad, but true.

{"commentId":4596376,"threadId":"455900","contentId":"2256373","authorDomain":"yellowknife-street-railway"}
  • 1 vote
#30.2 - Tue Dec 30, 2008 9:31 AM EST
{"commentId":4607176,"authorDomain":"jhavok"}
jimmy havok-596667Deleted
Reply
{"commentId":4595102,"authorDomain":"pakmanjonzun"}

Well now, who knew that bush was the biggest victim of them all.

Everybody is always picking on poor w.

Well you wont have w to kick around anymore.

{"commentId":4595102,"threadId":"455900","contentId":"2256373","authorDomain":"pakmanjonzun"}
  • 2 votes
Reply#31 - Tue Dec 30, 2008 6:13 AM EST
{"commentId":4596210,"authorDomain":"pdw174"}

As they say in a church I used to go to, "Thank you, Jesus!"

{"commentId":4596210,"threadId":"455900","contentId":"2256373","authorDomain":"pdw174"}
  • 2 votes
#31.1 - Tue Dec 30, 2008 9:15 AM EST
Reply
{"commentId":4595162,"authorDomain":"jopocop"}

Dan Barlett was a huge apologist and defender of Bush, where he appeared on many TV shows to uphold "everything" that Bush did as being valid, right, and best for America.  

With Barlett saying that the Katrina fiasco was a turning point and nail in the coffin for Bush, lends great credibility to this being true.  So, Barlett himself is putting another nail in the coffin for Bush's legacy.

Bush goes out soon with no parades and no public adulation, which is another item of proof of his dismal legacy.

When Bush saw the Obama victory celebration and huge excited crowds, Bush knew there what it meant to be popular in reality, which he was not.

{"commentId":4595162,"threadId":"455900","contentId":"2256373","authorDomain":"jopocop"}
  • 2 votes
Reply#32 - Tue Dec 30, 2008 6:35 AM EST
{"commentId":4595317,"authorDomain":"gravity32"}

When history is written it won't be Katrina that is called the turning point, it will be 9/11, the tragedy he knew was coming but worked to allow to happen and even helped.

{"commentId":4595317,"threadId":"455900","contentId":"2256373","authorDomain":"gravity32"}
  • 3 votes
Reply#33 - Tue Dec 30, 2008 7:22 AM EST
{"commentId":4596312,"authorDomain":"rhwengr"}

Its all Pres. Bushes fault.   Mayor, Governor and senator of the state of Louisiana, had no part in the failure of the state in the emergency.    Of course, the Governor and senator of Mississippi have no supporters for doing the right thing and getting their state back on track.    And, lets not forget Florida.    These two states seem to have their head together when it comes to emergencies, but Louisiana doesn't have a clue.    I wonder when the Louisiana statesman or stateswomen are going to be blamed for the inept handling of their own state?    I wonder where the millions sent to the State, for the levy repair went?    As to recovering after Katrina, for the Pres., it was the population and the news that let him down.   Its the states responsibility to declare emergencies and support their citizens, even before the U.S. Government gets involved.   Mississippi and Florida declared emergencies even before the hurricanes hit.    Wonder what happened to Louisiana?

{"commentId":4596312,"threadId":"455900","contentId":"2256373","authorDomain":"rhwengr"}
  • 1 vote
Reply#34 - Tue Dec 30, 2008 9:26 AM EST
{"commentId":4596604,"authorDomain":"SAGG"}

Greg, dude, you're shouting against the tornado winds. You can scream as loud as you want in support of Bush, and don't get me wrong, that's your right, but I honestly think it ain't gonna do you no good (except to make you feel better). Bush. Was. Terrible. Period. After seeing the VAST majority of posters here, it's quite apparent to me who most are putting the blame on. George W. Bush. What is your possible motivation to defend the man? Are you being paid by the GOP to support him, or something? Were you one of the few who benefitted financially from his tax-cutting-for-the-rich policies? Just what are you getting out of this?

{"commentId":4596604,"threadId":"455900","contentId":"2256373","authorDomain":"SAGG"}
  • 3 votes
#34.1 - Tue Dec 30, 2008 9:49 AM EST
{"commentId":4596674,"authorDomain":"rhwengr"}

I Know, he was so bad, my company made more in 8 years than ever before.   The only ones screaming are the ones that couldn't handle their own state.    The only ones screaming are the ones that hated Pres. Bush from the start.    Of course, it was Pres. Bushes responsibility to claim a state of emergency for Louisiana, right.    This article is about Katrina.    My statements are about the article and the Katrina Failures.    The state failed their own people.    The U.S. Government gets involved after the fact and after the state requests the governments help by declaring and emergency.    The state also has the responsibility to start emergency help well before the government gets involved.

{"commentId":4596674,"threadId":"455900","contentId":"2256373","authorDomain":"rhwengr"}
  • 1 vote
#34.2 - Tue Dec 30, 2008 9:54 AM EST
{"commentId":4597105,"authorDomain":"SAGG"}

Greg, I've seen my fair share of disasters on TV, from tornados to earthquakes, and I've NEVER seen such incompetance from a Presidency in TERMS OF LEADING than from Bush II. While it's probably true that the local governments in Baton Rouge and New Orleans could've done more in Katrina, I think they did their best. Heck, Gov. Blanco saw the handwriting on the wall and didn't bother to run again. New Orleans' mayor Nagin ran after pleading his case, and won. Bush GAVE THE IMPRESSION that he wasn't doing his job, and THAT'S what at issue here. Flying over the city in Air Force One? Are you kidding me? The man should've been down there in the city! Telling his ex-horse trainer of a FEMA Director (not a good IMPRESSION to people upon further review, btw) that he's doing "A heckava job", while dead bodies are floating in the water around the city? Once again, Greg, it's the IMPRESSION of doing a competant job that Bush needed to do. He should've been down there immediately, literally swamping the area that rivalled Katrina itself. Clinton was there immediately in many of the disasters that happened under his Presidency, and Mr. Keith Lee Witt became almost legendary for getting the job done as FEMA Director under him--which made Clinton look good, and the citizens in the affected areas remembered that in voting for him later. While Bush may have thought letting the locals handle the situation first was the right thing to do, he should've given the IMPRESSION that he knew what he was doing. One of the hallmarks of good to great leadership is giving the IMPRESSION that you're doing something right. The point here is that Bush GAVE THE IMPRESSION that he wasn't doing something right. If you're ignoring that, then I feel sorry for you, sir, whether you want my pity or not. And that goes for the other 2 or 3 people on this board under this thread who feel the same way you do about Bush doing nothing wrong. Reality appears to be something you all seem to be sorely lacking in. THAT is why I asked you if you benefitted somehow from the President. Good day to you, sir.

{"commentId":4597105,"threadId":"455900","contentId":"2256373","authorDomain":"SAGG"}
  • 1 vote
#34.3 - Tue Dec 30, 2008 10:27 AM EST
{"commentId":4597540,"authorDomain":"rhwengr"}

What disasters under Clinton are you talking about?   Incase you missed it, and what you all complain about, its not the governments job to get involved in state issues, unless the state asks for it.  Remember?    As to Clinton, are you talking about the tower bombings.    I noticed there were alot of convictions on that.   The cole Bombing, I noticed all the persons involved were put in jail.    Osama Bin Laden, being handed to him.   I noticed Osama in jail now.    States, as everyone claims, should deal with their own issues.    Government does not and should not get involved with state issues unless asked.    Or should government run all aspects of the country.   Of course, if you think that way, you are for government control.    More often than not, when you have nothing to respond to, your agency can claim total competency.

{"commentId":4597540,"threadId":"455900","contentId":"2256373","authorDomain":"rhwengr"}
    #34.4 - Tue Dec 30, 2008 10:57 AM EST
    {"commentId":4598435,"authorDomain":"progar01"}

    And, lets not forget Florida.    These two states seem to have their head together when it comes to emergencies,

    I wouldn't exactly put it that way, Greg...  Florida is as much of a f-up when it comes to emergencies...  I distinctly remember sitting for over 8 hours in a parking lot (I-10) trying to evacuate for a hurricane and we had moved less than 10 miles from where we started...  The problem with Florida's evacuation routes is that I-95 on the east and I-75(?) on the west are both north/south evacuation routes...  You either hit I-10 (an east/west evacuation route) or Georgia (whose evacuation routes are also east/west) and you are now at a stand-still...  Not to mention, they only recently began instituting reverse-flow evacuation (being able to drive the opposite way on the other side of the freeway)...

    I understand what you're saying and Florida, for all of its hurricane preparedness "experience," has some things figured out -- but not nearly as much as you would think...  To a certain extent, all hurricane-prone states are in a catch-22:  if they declare emergency too early, it loses effectiveness for the next time -- and if they declare too late, you get New Orleans devastation...  It certainly isn't easy -- but that's what the EXPERTS (NOT an ex-horse trainer) get paid to know and understand and figure out...  That's their ONLY job...  So there is absolutely no excuse for the fed's after Katrina...  Yes, they were caught flat-footed and grossly, incompetently unprepared...  Even AFTER Katrina hit, though, there was plenty of room for improvement...  But you just can't teach leadership in 3 days and you certainly can't fix stupid...

    {"commentId":4598435,"threadId":"455900","contentId":"2256373","authorDomain":"progar01"}
    • 1 vote
    #34.5 - Tue Dec 30, 2008 11:54 AM EST
    {"commentId":4598636,"authorDomain":"rhwengr"}

    I, for one, live in Florida, during all the hurricanes (and I still do) , and never once lost power and never once had to evacuate but FEMA came to my house, even though I claimed no damage, still gave me a flier on where to go and what to do, if I wanted to claim damage.    Of course I did the right thing and claimed no damage, even though I replaced my roof after the hurricanes.   I believe in taking responsibility for myself instead of taking advantage of tax payer money, which is where FEMA money comes from.  I was a blue top baby for awhile.  Floridas Problem is highway evacuation routes, and people wanting light rail instead of highways.     Florida has exactly 3 major highways.    I-4, I-95 and I-75.    Back to New Orleans and Louisiana, it was the fault of the leaders of this state first, then U.S. Government second.    When you claiming a state of emergency before it happens, it puts the U.S. Government on alert, before the disaster occurs.    If it doesn't happen, at least they were alerted.    If the Government, after a real disaster happens and they were notified that you, as a state, was relying on them, doesn't respond, then you have a gripe.     Louisiana had no clue, so to Blame Pres. Bush for everything, makes no sense.

    {"commentId":4598636,"threadId":"455900","contentId":"2256373","authorDomain":"rhwengr"}
    • 1 vote
    #34.6 - Tue Dec 30, 2008 12:08 PM EST
    {"commentId":4599753,"authorDomain":"a0ted"}

    And the Dems in Congress gave a Hail Mary to the incompetent Governor Blanco. Good that she decided not to run. She was not up for the job.

    Also the Rep. Lewis used the Armed Forces for his personal use. All was on TV recorded.

    {"commentId":4599753,"threadId":"455900","contentId":"2256373","authorDomain":"a0ted"}
    • 1 vote
    #34.7 - Tue Dec 30, 2008 1:14 PM EST
    {"commentId":4599830,"authorDomain":"rhwengr"}

    Agreed.    Must have known it was a screw up or would have run again.   To bad for the people of Louisiana, they voted those people in, including the worst of them, Nagin.    Remember the comment "making this city chocolate again"?  What a leader.    Of course, he was the first one out with his family.

    {"commentId":4599830,"threadId":"455900","contentId":"2256373","authorDomain":"rhwengr"}
      #34.8 - Tue Dec 30, 2008 1:18 PM EST
      {"commentId":4600453,"authorDomain":"luckydog"}

      Blanco and Naigin were incompetent absolutely but that does not excuse Bush who as usual left matters to his subordinates who were also incompetent. At some point he could have awakened from his stupor and taken action but he did not until the tragedy had played out far too long on T.V. and the country started calling for heads to roll.

      {"commentId":4600453,"threadId":"455900","contentId":"2256373","authorDomain":"luckydog"}
      • 5 votes
      #34.9 - Tue Dec 30, 2008 1:46 PM EST
      {"commentId":4600690,"authorDomain":"rhwengr"}

         Its still not the governments responsibility to get into state issues unless requested.    Its that complaint  by us, as to states being able to do without government intervention, unless you hate Pres. Bush.   Mississippi did well as did Florida.    Did Louisiana declare emergencies before or after the hurricane?    If after, how long do you think it takes the government to asses the problem, figure out what is needed and then to get emergency items together, based on the assessment.   Minutes? Hours? Days?    Your talking about government now and not military discipline.  What happened to the states police, fire etc...   Oohh, that's right, they were out of the area with their families also.    The heads that should have rolled were the states government.

      {"commentId":4600690,"threadId":"455900","contentId":"2256373","authorDomain":"rhwengr"}
        #34.10 - Tue Dec 30, 2008 1:57 PM EST
        {"commentId":4600979,"authorDomain":"keavinkirby"}

        People need to understand one thing that made Katrina so amazingly destructive: New orleans is a major city, and is between the Mississippi River, and the Bayou and Gulf of Mexico. The potential for catastrophe is far greater than hitting the Florida Panhandle or rural areas. It would be like a Cat 5 hitting Miami smack in the face. Don't matter who the Governer is. All that water and lots of poor people with no way out of town leads to high death tolls.

        {"commentId":4600979,"threadId":"455900","contentId":"2256373","authorDomain":"keavinkirby"}
        • 2 votes
        #34.11 - Tue Dec 30, 2008 2:12 PM EST
        {"commentId":4601169,"authorDomain":"rhwengr"}

            I understand the problem, of a major city, being constructed below sea level.  The issue is, did state government do what was required, or hit the road, to protect themselves?   As all complain about, government intervention in state affairs are frowned upon, unless its Pres. Bush.    Then its Pres. Bushes fault, for not intervening in state affairs.    And, Again, what happened to the government money (our tax money) sent to Louisiana, for the levee protection program, that still isn't complete?   State representatives are the issue and how well they handle an emergency.    The failure in Louisiana shows that the elected officials in that state, could not handle an emergency and need to be voted out.    Mississippi had devastation, but they sure weren't in the news much.    Louisiana had a way to get the poor out, but the officials, including the fire department, police and the mayor, were already safe in another state.

        {"commentId":4601169,"threadId":"455900","contentId":"2256373","authorDomain":"rhwengr"}
        • 1 vote
        #34.12 - Tue Dec 30, 2008 2:21 PM EST
        {"commentId":4601414,"authorDomain":"a0ted"}

        State of Emergency is signed after hurricanes. In Katrina we all were watching what was coming and GWB signed it 4 days before starting hitting.

        {"commentId":4601414,"threadId":"455900","contentId":"2256373","authorDomain":"a0ted"}
        • 3 votes
        #34.13 - Tue Dec 30, 2008 2:34 PM EST
        {"commentId":4601508,"authorDomain":"lisaed"}

        determined---what we learned with katrina is that the federal government will get the entire blame (so long as sitting president is GOP and local government on the ground is DEM) when disaster hits. And then those dems on the ground who did naught to avert that disaster to strike like Mayor Nagin get re-elected. I've a cousin who lives in New Orleans---and I feel much better knowing there's a new governor in town.

        {"commentId":4601508,"threadId":"455900","contentId":"2256373","authorDomain":"lisaed"}
        • 2 votes
        #34.14 - Tue Dec 30, 2008 2:38 PM EST
        {"commentId":4602558,"authorDomain":"lazaruslong"}

        Did anyone else happen to notice that Mr. McCain won by large margins in all three of the "Katrina states?"  Think on that just a bit.

        {"commentId":4602558,"threadId":"455900","contentId":"2256373","authorDomain":"lazaruslong"}
          #34.15 - Tue Dec 30, 2008 3:34 PM EST
          {"commentId":4603047,"authorDomain":"optimismrachel"}

          Federal government is not here to operate state level emergencies. It can grant emergency aid and send down FEMA but that's about it. Being proactive and preparing for disaster is the state's job. Did you blame Clinton because people wouldn't leave their homes in the midwest during the floods? Did you blame Clinton for the mid-Atlantic blizzard of 1996?

          Bush did his part and he rightfully expected the Louisiana government to have common sense and concern for their residents. Since they obviously had neither, Bush probably felt bad because by doing his job and not doing everyone else's, people had to suffer. Since when is it the president's job to take over everyone else's job? Isn't that called dictator?

          {"commentId":4603047,"threadId":"455900","contentId":"2256373","authorDomain":"optimismrachel"}
          • 2 votes
          #34.16 - Tue Dec 30, 2008 4:00 PM EST
          {"commentId":4603145,"authorDomain":"rhwengr"}

          The state of emergency was signed by Pres. Bush, 2 days prior but did not include parts of Luoisianna's parishes because Gov. Blanco had not included these parrishes in her initial request for emergency help.   After the hearing Gov. Blanco did release a letter showing more areas than were originally shown.   On the 26th, Mississippi activated its National Gaurd in preperation of the storms landfall and the state had activated its emergency center requiring emergency evacuations.    On the 28th, Pres. Bush spoke with Gov. Blanco to encourage mandatory evacuation, mainly because the Governor had not done it yet.   Nagin did issue a mandatory evac. order on the 28th, and had the superdome used as a last resort, stocked with food and water, for the poor, who could not evacuate the city.  Alittle late, since the Hurricane hit on the 29th.  Problem was, there was no follow up by the state, once this superdome was filled, and the storm past.    Florida Gov. Jeb Bush Declared a State of Emergency on the 24th and required either voluntary evacuations or mandatory evacuations in Marion County.

          {"commentId":4603145,"threadId":"455900","contentId":"2256373","authorDomain":"rhwengr"}
          • 1 vote
          #34.17 - Tue Dec 30, 2008 4:05 PM EST
          {"commentId":4603505,"authorDomain":"a0ted"}

          Gracie,

          The best evacuation plan is to have a relative in another State.

          How come I haven't heard the same story from my brother-in-law and friends that live in Miami?

          {"commentId":4603505,"threadId":"455900","contentId":"2256373","authorDomain":"a0ted"}
          • 2 votes
          #34.18 - Tue Dec 30, 2008 4:27 PM EST
          {"commentId":4604428,"authorDomain":"yellowknife-street-railway"}

          Young Hot and Not to Smart

          Federal government is not here to operate state level emergencies. It can grant emergency aid and send down FEMA but that's about it. Being proactive and preparing for disaster is the state's job. Did you blame Clinton because people wouldn't leave their homes in the midwest during the floods? Did you blame Clinton for the mid-Atlantic blizzard of 1996?

          Bush did his part and he rightfully expected the Louisiana government to have common sense and concern for their residents. Since they obviously had neither, Bush probably felt bad because by doing his job and not doing everyone else's, people had to suffer. Since when is it the president's job to take over everyone else's job? Isn't that called dictator?

          Did this baseless information come to you in a dream. You have no clue as to what FEMA is supposed to do. As to Bush "probably felt bad because he was doing his job" is one of the dumbest things I have ever heard. Is your name Laura Bush or are you just stupid ?

          {"commentId":4604428,"threadId":"455900","contentId":"2256373","authorDomain":"yellowknife-street-railway"}
          • 3 votes
          #34.19 - Tue Dec 30, 2008 5:23 PM EST
          {"commentId":4604611,"authorDomain":"rhwengr"}

          M.white bear:   You must believe in government control.   There are states rights and responsibilities that the government is supposed to stay away from.    If the state fails, then government should step in, so as to Louisiana, you must be claiming the state failed, with liberal representatives, and the conservative President should have stepped in sooner.

          {"commentId":4604611,"threadId":"455900","contentId":"2256373","authorDomain":"rhwengr"}
          • 1 vote
          #34.20 - Tue Dec 30, 2008 5:37 PM EST
          {"commentId":4605262,"authorDomain":"yellowknife-street-railway"}

          greg-709692

          M.white bear:   You must believe in government control.   There are states rights and responsibilities that the government is supposed to stay away from.    If the state fails, then government should step in, so as to Louisiana, you must be claiming the state failed, with liberal representatives, and the conservative President should have stepped in sooner.

          No, I believe in the federal government doing its job. When something this huge overwhelms local governments, the feds are supposed to come in, with the BIG equipment, money, troops, etc.

          Why do you Southerners keep mentioning 'states rights'. Don't you guys know you lost that argument in 1865, duh.

          I do understand your pain since you lost again last month, get over it, America won, you guys LOST.

          This blog is really about that failure in the White House, not the hurricane, etc.

          {"commentId":4605262,"threadId":"455900","contentId":"2256373","authorDomain":"yellowknife-street-railway"}
          • 3 votes
          #34.21 - Tue Dec 30, 2008 6:31 PM EST
          {"commentId":4605879,"authorDomain":"SAGG"}

          M. White bear, you da one! And Greg, one more thing: How in the heck do you explain Bush telling "Brownie, you're doing one heck of a job.", when "Brownie" wasn't? If the disaster gets too big for the locals, it's time for Uncle Sam to step in, as I'm sure your boy more than pushed with the $700 billion dollar bailout. Did you agree with that, too? Did you agree with out of control spending from a supposedly CONSERVATIVE President that's increased our deficit to new heights? How do you explain THAT?

          {"commentId":4605879,"threadId":"455900","contentId":"2256373","authorDomain":"SAGG"}
          • 3 votes
          #34.22 - Tue Dec 30, 2008 7:32 PM EST
          {"commentId":4611333,"authorDomain":"progar01"}

           How come I haven't heard the same story from my brother-in-law and friends that live in Miami?

          Determined -- I don't know the answer to that...  All I can suppose is maybe because they are at the southern end of the state and only have one way to go -- north...  I used to live in Jacksonville, where the evacuation route is either I-95 to the north or I-10 to the west...  And we had to make our decisions rather early, because once they issued the Hurricane Warning, all bridges were closed -- and since there's 7 major bridges in Jacksonville, you were hard pressed to try and get out of town without going over one of them...  A major hurricane hasn't made landfall in Jacksonville since the 60's, if I'm correct -- so people there are pretty complacent...  The one we bugged out for (I forget which one and which year) wasn't even the biggest of the year -- but it was after the fiasco of sitting on the freeway parking lot that the local powers that be decided they finally needed to institute reverse-flow traffic when evacuations were either ordered or voluntary so that people wouldn't be sitting in their cars on the freeway when it hit...

          {"commentId":4611333,"threadId":"455900","contentId":"2256373","authorDomain":"progar01"}
            #34.23 - Wed Dec 31, 2008 10:06 AM EST
            {"commentId":4616974,"authorDomain":"geejay"}

            determined---what we learned with katrina is that the federal government will get the entire blame (so long as sitting president is GOP and local government on the ground is DEM

            Ah, Republican victimhood.  A good reason why the GOP won't be seeing the presidency for a long while.

            {"commentId":4616974,"threadId":"455900","contentId":"2256373","authorDomain":"geejay"}
            • 4 votes
            #34.24 - Wed Dec 31, 2008 5:08 PM EST
            Reply
            {"commentId":4596467,"authorDomain":"yellowknife-street-railway"}

            Nice job guys, it is now 9:39am

             The score is 68 against Bush and only 3 knuckleheads defending him. Imagine that.

            OBAMA 2012

            {"commentId":4596467,"threadId":"455900","contentId":"2256373","authorDomain":"yellowknife-street-railway"}
            • 7 votes
            Reply#35 - Tue Dec 30, 2008 9:39 AM EST
            {"commentId":4596561,"authorDomain":"crustyfliss"}

            Katrina was just the 1st of many major blunders this POTUS has made.  I'll never forget that video of Bush with his arm around FEMA Director Brown and gleefully stating, "you're doing a fine job Brownie" - at the very moment that thousands were homeless and still in the streets of New Orleans.

            This man is in a word - clueless!  America and the world will be much better off without him.

            {"commentId":4596561,"threadId":"455900","contentId":"2256373","authorDomain":"crustyfliss"}
            • 5 votes
            Reply#36 - Tue Dec 30, 2008 9:47 AM EST
            {"commentId":4597034,"authorDomain":"ronco104"}

            there is certainly nothing i could say,  that yall haven't said,  and better than i EVER could...thank yall very much and just remember,   obama will soon be THE president.    it has to get better that it is right now!!!

            luv,

            ron

            {"commentId":4597034,"threadId":"455900","contentId":"2256373","authorDomain":"ronco104"}
            • 4 votes
            Reply#37 - Tue Dec 30, 2008 10:22 AM EST
            {"commentId":4597192,"authorDomain":"terry57"}

            Barbara Bush Calls Evacuees Better Off

            The New York Times (9/6/05)

            Barbara Bush declared it a success for evacuees who "were underpriviledged anyway". saying that many poor people she had seen while touring a Houston relocation site were faring better than before the storm hit. "What I'm hearing, which is sort of scarey, is they all want to stay in Texas". "And so many of the people in the arena here, you know, were underpriviledged anyway, so this is working very well for them."

            This comment buy bushies mommy should tell everyone about his upbrining and why he didn't care about new orleans,,,, he doesn't care about the impoverished or underpriviledged,,,  only the rich

            {"commentId":4597192,"threadId":"455900","contentId":"2256373","authorDomain":"terry57"}
            • 5 votes
            Reply#38 - Tue Dec 30, 2008 10:33 AM EST
            {"commentId":4599043,"authorDomain":"wfcmchicago"}

            When I first read her quote I was in shock. It just goes to show that the Bush family does not live in the same America as the rest of us. This is why Dubya can say that we're not in a recession (because his family doesn't have to deal with it) when the rest of us know that we are.

            {"commentId":4599043,"threadId":"455900","contentId":"2256373","authorDomain":"wfcmchicago"}
            • 1 vote
            #38.1 - Tue Dec 30, 2008 12:36 PM EST
            {"commentId":4599463,"authorDomain":"terry57"}

             What I'm hearing, which is sort of scarey, is they all want to stay in Texas 

            I just really noticed this little part,,,,,scarey for who Bab's???????  Afraid the black folk won't go home??

            {"commentId":4599463,"threadId":"455900","contentId":"2256373","authorDomain":"terry57"}
            • 2 votes
            #38.2 - Tue Dec 30, 2008 1:00 PM EST
            Reply
            {"commentId":4597251,"authorDomain":"showpro"}

            The question is not weather he has or has not recovered from Katrina, but will we ever recover from his presidency?

            That is the question!

            {"commentId":4597251,"threadId":"455900","contentId":"2256373","authorDomain":"showpro"}
            • 2 votes
            Reply#39 - Tue Dec 30, 2008 10:37 AM EST
            {"commentId":4597301,"authorDomain":"maxhousewell"}

            1. Bush never did and still doesn't know the State of The Union.
            2. People still haven't recovered from Katrina. So is this a statement of boohoo for Bush ?
            3. As Bush has demonstrated through out his term, he's more comfortable speaking to people on or below his level of intelligence, third grade students fit his comfort zone.
            4. He's never been a leader or a success in any of his life ventures.

            Ex-Bush aides say he never recovered from Katrina

                  5. Bush never recovered from his drug and alcohol use.

            {"commentId":4597301,"threadId":"455900","contentId":"2256373","authorDomain":"maxhousewell"}
            • 2 votes
            Reply#40 - Tue Dec 30, 2008 10:40 AM EST
            {"commentId":4597308,"authorDomain":"Surf7"}
            Surf7Deleted
            {"commentId":4597334,"authorDomain":"Aunk"}

            Hetep and Respect, for one hundred years anytime someone mentions a Republican, someone should scream "REMEMBER KATRINA". No anti-humanist Republican like bush and the forty thieves should be allowed near the White House for a hundred years.

            {"commentId":4597334,"threadId":"455900","contentId":"2256373","authorDomain":"Aunk"}
            • 6 votes
            Reply#42 - Tue Dec 30, 2008 10:43 AM EST
            {"commentId":4597531,"authorDomain":"Zoilus"}

            Hetep and Respect, Aunk
            If only America had an 'Ignore" button, they'd have put the Republican party on it by now.

            {"commentId":4597531,"threadId":"455900","contentId":"2256373","authorDomain":"Zoilus"}
            • 5 votes
            #42.1 - Tue Dec 30, 2008 10:57 AM EST
            {"commentId":4604033,"authorDomain":"Aunk"}

            H&R Zoilus, good Idea. Republican anti-humanist Ignore button pushed, set to reset in 100 years.

            {"commentId":4604033,"threadId":"455900","contentId":"2256373","authorDomain":"Aunk"}
            • 3 votes
            #42.2 - Tue Dec 30, 2008 4:58 PM EST
            Reply
            {"commentId":4597541,"authorDomain":"crustyfliss"}

            Any POTUS worth his salt would have called the Gov of Louisiana and gotten her to sign off on the use of the US military from day one.  Sure, you can say this is revisionist history  - but there was no mistaking the misery that was occuring on my TV. Surely someone in the Bush administration watches TV. No?

            What galls me is how the entire Bush administration failed to do anything for 3 days. That is not something any American should ever forget.  They failed miserably.  Leave the White House already!

            {"commentId":4597541,"threadId":"455900","contentId":"2256373","authorDomain":"crustyfliss"}
            • 3 votes
            Reply#43 - Tue Dec 30, 2008 10:57 AM EST
            {"commentId":4600029,"authorDomain":"yellowknife-street-railway"}

            Actually  it was a bit over 4 days.

            {"commentId":4600029,"threadId":"455900","contentId":"2256373","authorDomain":"yellowknife-street-railway"}
            • 3 votes
            #43.1 - Tue Dec 30, 2008 1:26 PM EST
            {"commentId":4603610,"authorDomain":"readermystery43"}

            And the illustrious mayor of New Orleans refused to evacuate citizens on school buses which were available for use.  People were lost and the buses destroyed.  Sure, Bush messed up.  But you also had a Democratic governor of the state and a Democratic mayor who screwed up too.  Point the blame to all who deserve it, not just your own choosing.  Why couldn't the governor and mayor make some of their own decisions before the hurricane struck.  It wasn't a national disaster until after the fact.  Sometimes preventive measures can save lives.  Nothing could be done about the property damage at the time, but you could have made people leave.  I notice everytime there is some sort of weather catastrophe that there are always people who remain behind.  Get them OUT.  Make them LEAVE. 

            {"commentId":4603610,"threadId":"455900","contentId":"2256373","authorDomain":"readermystery43"}
            • 2 votes
            #43.2 - Tue Dec 30, 2008 4:32 PM EST
            {"commentId":4604294,"authorDomain":"crustyfliss"}

            Nagin and the other state officals are all to blame. I'm simply pointing out that anyone watching the events on TV knew right away that this was not your garden variety hurricane. Somehow no one in the entire Bush White House got that message. Hence, we never heard a peek out of him for 4 days. By that time his reputation was ruined.

            {"commentId":4604294,"threadId":"455900","contentId":"2256373","authorDomain":"crustyfliss"}
            • 2 votes
            #43.3 - Tue Dec 30, 2008 5:14 PM EST
            {"commentId":4605000,"authorDomain":"bigblackguy"}

            I could be wrong about this because no comprehensive study has been done to date but consider the possibility for a moment:

            1) School Buses and City/County/Parish Transportation Bus Systems.

            2) Buses require drivers. People are still going about their daily lives until shortly before Hurricane Katrina makes landfall.

            3) At the moment that full evacuation mode is implemented, where are all of the school bus drivers, city/county and parish bus drivers? Can you ask the storm to hold back for a few hours while we install martial law and force the drivers to leave their own families and get them to drive these poor people to safety somewhere as yet unknown?

            This is a reasonably good illustration of why the Republican model is passe. Find a poor person to blame for the failure of our leaders and continue to attack anyone who brings the mirror to the President, so that he can find the greatest failure of leadership. The POTUS is NOT responsible for the destruction caused by Hurricane Katrina nor is he responsible for not having suitable evacuation plans in order.

            However, only the exceptionally deluded can conclude that "they should have left before the storm arrived". If you are poor, with no car and no money, how do you leave and where will you go? Who would protect the few meager items that you do possess? It is the ultimate indictment of "compassionate conservatism". It has the same validity as the trickle-down economic theory. Or the tax cut for corporations so that they will hire more people. Show me the data where any of those things have ever occurred.

            {"commentId":4605000,"threadId":"455900","contentId":"2256373","authorDomain":"bigblackguy"}
            • 3 votes
            #43.4 - Tue Dec 30, 2008 6:08 PM EST
            Reply
            {"commentId":4597833,"authorDomain":"a0ted"}
            That is not something any American should ever forget.  . 

            Not fair, the new POTUS has a competent Republican for Governor in NO. And who can forget about the temper tantrums of the Senator Landrieu?

            Instead of using the good money for the levees she embellished New Orleans for the purposes that we all know.

            {"commentId":4597833,"threadId":"455900","contentId":"2256373","authorDomain":"a0ted"}
            • 1 vote
            Reply#44 - Tue Dec 30, 2008 11:15 AM EST
            {"commentId":4598466,"authorDomain":"crustyfliss"}

            Not fair? On Day One of Katrina it was clear from watching TV that this was a major disaster.  Someone in the Bush administration should have gotten ahold of him in Crawford and convinced him to move on Day One.  I am simply saying that his entire administration failed him and he made it even worse by arriving on Day Three and putting his arm around FEMA Director Mike Brown (who had ZERO experience in disaster relief) and saying, "you're doing a heck of a job Brownie", while dead bodies were floating in the streets...

            Uh, he was a complete failure as a POTUS.

            {"commentId":4598466,"threadId":"455900","contentId":"2256373","authorDomain":"crustyfliss"}
            • 4 votes
            #44.1 - Tue Dec 30, 2008 11:56 AM EST
            {"commentId":4600420,"authorDomain":"a0ted"}

            Oh come on. Why in the heck a State have US Senators/Governor, Mayor and Representative.

            Those politicians didn't need to be told, of course for elections they run a perfect traffic line for buses.

            The Dems talk about the world poverty, well, I haven't read, watch a thing about starting the charity in New Orleans and Mississippi.

            {"commentId":4600420,"threadId":"455900","contentId":"2256373","authorDomain":"a0ted"}
            • 2 votes
            #44.2 - Tue Dec 30, 2008 1:44 PM EST
            Reply
            {"commentId":4598158,"authorDomain":"Zoilus"}

            Republicans under the Neo-cons are like little spoiled rotten, brat children, who have always gotten their way, and finally have been put in their place and disciplined for breaking mommies lamp... again.

            Now all they can do is throw tantrums about how unfair they are being treated and how mean everyone is to them, and can't understand why no one believes them anymore or wants to hear anything they have to say, when all they do is keep lying, by trying to blame their brother for everything they did. 

            {"commentId":4598158,"threadId":"455900","contentId":"2256373","authorDomain":"Zoilus"}
            • 5 votes
            Reply#45 - Tue Dec 30, 2008 11:35 AM EST
            {"commentId":4599167,"authorDomain":"Surf7"}
            Surf7Deleted
            {"commentId":4600439,"authorDomain":"tyroanee"}

            Hey Surf7

            We as a nation have ONE HELL of a CLEAN-UP wouldn't you agree?

            So to place it on one man would be lame!

            I don't place the blame on Bush... I blame his band of merry idiots also... So let's try to think outside the box here... This country is in shambles so start pitching in or quit complaining... I volunteered in our community while Bush was in office ~~ Do you think you can do the same to help this great nation or perhaps you already do?

            {"commentId":4600439,"threadId":"455900","contentId":"2256373","authorDomain":"tyroanee"}
            • 4 votes
            #45.2 - Tue Dec 30, 2008 1:45 PM EST
            {"commentId":4601110,"authorDomain":"Surf7"}
            Surf7Deleted
            {"commentId":4604048,"authorDomain":"tyroanee"}

            No Surf7

            That's the point your service is needed throughout your lifetime, there is no time limit or amount of hours... You just do it because it makes you a better person, for helping someone out when they needed it.

            The freedom that I share? Yes we all have had sacrifices in our families, but no one family is more American or not Patriotic enough because we want Peace.

            To say you have done your part... It saddened me to think you are all washed up done, hands in the air Fin.

            Wow, I plan on volunteering until I am scattered at sea...Just think of all the wasted opportunities you have let pass by... you could have met some really wonderful people.

            But most of all I THANK YOU FOR HELPING OUR NATION and our whole world with FREEDOM>

            {"commentId":4604048,"threadId":"455900","contentId":"2256373","authorDomain":"tyroanee"}
            • 1 vote
            #45.4 - Tue Dec 30, 2008 4:59 PM EST
            {"commentId":4605759,"authorDomain":"Surf7"}
            Surf7Deleted
            {"commentId":4606830,"authorDomain":"Zoilus"}

            If you want to make war, get a warrior, if you want peace Get a peace maker.

            {"commentId":4606830,"threadId":"455900","contentId":"2256373","authorDomain":"Zoilus"}
            • 3 votes
            #45.6 - Tue Dec 30, 2008 9:14 PM EST
            {"commentId":4609011,"authorDomain":"Surf7"}
            Surf7Deleted
            Reply
            {"commentId":4598417,"authorDomain":"buddysej"}

            Never Recovered from Katrina?  uhmmmmmmmmmm,  He's not the only one who never recovered!  And his coffin nails started surely before Katrina - nail one was his campaign and election; nail two was that "Mission Accomplished" farce and the nails just continued. 

            He never recovered......... ????????     So how many "refugees" are at the Bush ranch, I wonder?   He never recovered?  Will the American people as a whole recover from the Bush phenom?

            ...nice wreath though.......... 

            {"commentId":4598417,"threadId":"455900","contentId":"2256373","authorDomain":"buddysej"}
            • 6 votes
            Reply#46 - Tue Dec 30, 2008 11:52 AM EST
            {"commentId":4598784,"authorDomain":"jopocop"}

            Once Bush is out and gone, his punishment should be to read every anti-Bush comment since his election in 2000.

            Maybe then he will have a clue.

            {"commentId":4598784,"threadId":"455900","contentId":"2256373","authorDomain":"jopocop"}
            • 2 votes
            Reply#47 - Tue Dec 30, 2008 12:19 PM EST
            {"commentId":4599197,"authorDomain":"watersportgirl"}

            I'm thankful we have a free country where we can debate politics in such a fashion.  To be sure, the Democrats will also be judged harshly, as Bush has. 

            I really think the problem is that most politicians do not truly represent American ideas and values.  They are elected on political platforms, then are sent a nice salary and off to Washington they go.  There they get corrupted (even those with the best intentions) with "vote for my bill; I'll vote for yours" and loading up the pork into the barrels of politics.

            Approximately 230 years ago, the representation of this country was founded during the horse and buggy days, when it would be impossible for each citizen's voice to be heard.  But now we have such mass communication technology, I really do not see the point in this. 

            However, rather than dismantling the precious constitution, I would like to see the mass communication highlight each politician's budget, voting record and campaign contributions.

            Forget C-span.  It's too sedating.  Get the info to the masses of people -- the majority who vote out of ignorance in a high-school popularity voting fashion. 

            The future of our country depends on rational thought based on facts and history, not the "entertainment" news we have now.  I agree with the previous poster that we get the president we deserve....(at least, the majority deserve).  We need to enlighten the ignorant majority. 

            I do not care if people's opinion is aligned with or against mine - only that it is informed!

            {"commentId":4599197,"threadId":"455900","contentId":"2256373","authorDomain":"watersportgirl"}
            • 3 votes
            Reply#48 - Tue Dec 30, 2008 12:46 PM EST
            {"commentId":4599837,"authorDomain":"inglett9"}

            The problem with your idea of reporting on each office holders results, would be that the voters of each state don't agree with the opinions of other states. We would be back to a federated government where each state controlled what laws they would enforce and how they would have their National Representatives vote. The problem is....the people we elect, but the larger problem is the Party control of State Politics. Strong party affiliations have more influence on how votes are cast, not who may be the best candidate, always has been this way probably will never change. You have an idea with good intentions but the strength of each party will never allow a perfect government. The majority of people who run for office are very ambitious and very opinionated about their abilities. They believe they are the only ones with the answers.

            {"commentId":4599837,"threadId":"455900","contentId":"2256373","authorDomain":"inglett9"}
            • 1 vote
            #48.1 - Tue Dec 30, 2008 1:18 PM EST
            {"commentId":4600472,"authorDomain":"a0ted"}

            Our elections are not for ideals they are who has more backing money and it does not matter the source.

            {"commentId":4600472,"threadId":"455900","contentId":"2256373","authorDomain":"a0ted"}
            • 2 votes
            #48.2 - Tue Dec 30, 2008 1:47 PM EST
            {"commentId":4601142,"authorDomain":"Zoilus"}

            Gene, the problem with your criticism of WSG's post shows an epistemic ignorance in civics. If you were an immigrant, you wouldn't pass the exam to become a Citizens..

             We would be back to a federated government where each state controlled what laws they would enforce and how they would have their National Representatives vote. 

            That is exactly what happens.

            We are a Democratic-republic, Democatic at the state and local level, and part of a federation of States, a republic of sovereign states each with their own State Constitutions. Federal Laws, State Laws. There are no LEADERS in the US Constitution, only representatives of the people.

            {"commentId":4601142,"threadId":"455900","contentId":"2256373","authorDomain":"Zoilus"}
            • 4 votes
            #48.3 - Tue Dec 30, 2008 2:19 PM EST
            {"commentId":4617277,"authorDomain":"inglett9"}

            If you look back to how our government was administered prior to 1787 it was not the government we live by today. It was a federation of states with a very weak central government. The states would ignore the laws of border states and administer taxes on goods from them. The leadership (representatives) they sent to the Continental Congress would only cast votes that were in favor of their state. I believe the civics and government classes I've taken would allow me to pass an immigration test. Excuse me, show me where I talk about leaders. I mentioned National Representatives(Senators and Representatives). Now look at whatever state you reside in and tell me if the people plot their course of government or do the major parties run whoever they want for office and make the policy they want, not the people.

            {"commentId":4617277,"threadId":"455900","contentId":"2256373","authorDomain":"inglett9"}
            • 1 vote
            #48.4 - Wed Dec 31, 2008 5:44 PM EST
            {"commentId":4617426,"authorDomain":"inglett9"}

            I really didn't think I was being critical of watersportgirl, only presenting a view that due to party influence and affiliation it would be very unlikely that we would have an accounting of each politician. It would become, just as we have now, partisan. I think it would be great if an accurate accounting of what our elected reps do to make our lives better. But it would also require each citizen of each state to vote to oust the bad members. Won't ever happen.

            {"commentId":4617426,"threadId":"455900","contentId":"2256373","authorDomain":"inglett9"}
              #48.5 - Wed Dec 31, 2008 6:01 PM EST
              Reply
              {"commentId":4600547,"authorDomain":"Mars313"}

              Never recovered? Never recovered what? Did he own property in the 9th ward? Did one of his corporate f*ck-buddies die in Katrina? What the hell did he lose? He didn't lose sleep. He didn't lose vacation time. He didn't lose money or his "job". What didn't he recover?

              {"commentId":4600547,"threadId":"455900","contentId":"2256373","authorDomain":"Mars313"}
              • 7 votes
              Reply#49 - Tue Dec 30, 2008 1:50 PM EST
              {"commentId":4600732,"authorDomain":"wainiha3"}

              What???  You are saying he had all these experts around him to get him out of the Palin mode, and yet they could not assist in Katrina?  Be serious.

              Katrina was a well defined, easily recognizable problem.  It had no international consequences; it had no mutually exclusive religious or political philosophies; it had no hundreds/ thousands of years of tradition to overcome.  The outlining of the problem was easy.  The defining of the solution was easy

              It might have taken a lot of money and competent management but it could have been done.  All Katrina was was a secondary nuisance to the "war president".  He was not  interested in it.

              He did not do any thing more than minimal PR actions and talk.  Now, that he realizes that his thousands of displaced still suffering New Orleans citizens are going to hold his lack of help against him its spin time.

              {"commentId":4600732,"threadId":"455900","contentId":"2256373","authorDomain":"wainiha3"}
              • 4 votes
              Reply#50 - Tue Dec 30, 2008 1:59 PM EST
              {"commentId":4600819,"authorDomain":"watersportgirl"}

              Spot on.

              LOL.....the recovery he's probably talking about is his popularity.  <<<roll eyes>>>

              {"commentId":4600819,"threadId":"455900","contentId":"2256373","authorDomain":"watersportgirl"}
              • 2 votes
              #50.1 - Tue Dec 30, 2008 2:03 PM EST
              Reply
              {"commentId":4600847,"authorDomain":"caesara"}

              A stupid position to take, one with a mountain of evidence to disprove it: had he gotten Katrina "right" all else would have fallen into place. It was as we ALL know simply another, albeit huge, fiasco inevitably stemming from his orthodox right wing ideological extremism twinned with his particular brand of callous and shallow incompetence.  

              {"commentId":4600847,"threadId":"455900","contentId":"2256373","authorDomain":"caesara"}
              • 1 vote
              Reply#51 - Tue Dec 30, 2008 2:05 PM EST
              {"commentId":4601050,"authorDomain":"a0ted"}

              Oh, please.

              Are the next hurricanes to be more benigns because Obama is the President?

              Blind partisanship does not help with the situation.

              I read the previous evacuation plan of LA/NA and they only needed to add: Bring your Blackberry phone.

              {"commentId":4601050,"threadId":"455900","contentId":"2256373","authorDomain":"a0ted"}
              • 2 votes
              #51.1 - Tue Dec 30, 2008 2:15 PM EST
              {"commentId":4601187,"authorDomain":"Mars313"}

              Are the next hurricanes to be more benigns because Obama is the President?

              No, but I doubt he would ignore that ever happened like your boy did. God forbid he, as President, shorten his vacation to help the people who he governs. Do you keep your expectations so low in order to keep from being disappointed?

              Blind partisanship does not help with the situation.

              Which is why you and your party are absolutely ineffective in fixing anything at all.

              {"commentId":4601187,"threadId":"455900","contentId":"2256373","authorDomain":"Mars313"}
              • 4 votes
              #51.2 - Tue Dec 30, 2008 2:22 PM EST
              {"commentId":4603086,"authorDomain":"optimismrachel"}

              Are you suggesting President Bush should have got into a boat himself and starting picking people out of the city? That was pretty much underwater and on fire at one point? How do you know Bush wasn't communicating with people on the matter, or that no one was delegated to oversee the issue? You don't know because reporters don't know.

              {"commentId":4603086,"threadId":"455900","contentId":"2256373","authorDomain":"optimismrachel"}
              • 1 vote
              #51.3 - Tue Dec 30, 2008 4:02 PM EST
              {"commentId":4603534,"authorDomain":"a0ted"}

              Yes, this is the implication and I gave an example of GWB wearing a Superman/Spiderman suit stopping Katrina.

              {"commentId":4603534,"threadId":"455900","contentId":"2256373","authorDomain":"a0ted"}
              • 1 vote
              #51.4 - Tue Dec 30, 2008 4:28 PM EST
              {"commentId":4605373,"authorDomain":"aine"}

              Maybe he should've put down the guitar and headed up the federal side of the rescue and relief efforts. Meanwhile, the man who actually won the popular vote for POTUS in 2000, Al Gore helped airlift some 270 Katrina evacuees on two private charters from New Orleans.

              {"commentId":4605373,"threadId":"455900","contentId":"2256373","authorDomain":"aine"}
              • 3 votes
              #51.5 - Tue Dec 30, 2008 6:42 PM EST
              {"commentId":4605653,"authorDomain":"a0ted"}

              The PE O's campaign so tight lip and with almost military precision discipline could not control Blago in Chicago.

              {"commentId":4605653,"threadId":"455900","contentId":"2256373","authorDomain":"a0ted"}
              • 2 votes
              #51.6 - Tue Dec 30, 2008 7:08 PM EST
              {"commentId":4605668,"authorDomain":"a0ted"}

              Aine

              Did Al Gore greased his elbows for the black and poor in New Orleans before and during his 8 years in office?

              {"commentId":4605668,"threadId":"455900","contentId":"2256373","authorDomain":"a0ted"}
              • 1 vote
              #51.7 - Tue Dec 30, 2008 7:09 PM EST
              {"commentId":4606481,"authorDomain":"aine"}

              Expanded the Earned Income Tax Credit (providing $21 billion in relief for 15 million low-income families), passed/signed the Family and Medical Leave Act of 1993, improved economic conditions and policies such that low income people could afford the basic necessities (food, clothing, shelter) and spurred an increase in family incomes for all Americans, unemployment (including that of African-Americans which fell from 14.2 percent in 1992 to 7.3 percent in 2000, the lowest rate on record) dropped to the lowest level in more than 30 years, the poverty rate also declined from 15.1 percent in 1993 to 11.8 percent in 1999 (the largest six-year drop in poverty in nearly 30 years), made college more affordable by expanding the financial-aid program known as Pell grants and lowering interest rates on student loans, creation of more than 22.5 million jobs (the most jobs ever created under a single administration, and 92% of those were in the private sector),...

              these are just a few of the things accomplished by Clinton/Gore during their 8 years in office.

              {"commentId":4606481,"threadId":"455900","contentId":"2256373","authorDomain":"aine"}
              • 4 votes
              #51.8 - Tue Dec 30, 2008 8:35 PM EST
              {"commentId":4617011,"authorDomain":"geejay"}

              It was very telling of Bush's (lack of) character that he continued to vacation, smile and party as Katrina unfolded.

              I seriously doubt that Obama will go out and party during any tragedies, though if he does, I will hope that all of you excusing that behavior don't say a word.

              {"commentId":4617011,"threadId":"455900","contentId":"2256373","authorDomain":"geejay"}
              • 1 vote
              #51.9 - Wed Dec 31, 2008 5:12 PM EST
              Reply
              Jump to discussion page: 1 2 3
              {"canLink":false,"threadId":"455900","isPrivate":false}
              Leave a Comment:
              You're in Easy Mode. If you prefer, you can use XHTML Mode instead.
              As a new user, you may notice a few temporary content restrictions. Click here for more info.
              {"threadId":"455900","contentId":"2256373"}
              Start TrackingStart Tracking
              Stop TrackingStop Tracking