Newsvine
  • Welcome
  • Help
  • Report Bug
  • Conversation Tracker
  • Your Column
  • Replies
  • Friends
Type Comments Since You Last CheckedArticle Source Last Checked Stop Tracking All Clear Tracking All
Advertise | AdChoices
Log In | Register
Close the Login Panel
Existing users log in below. New users please register for a free account.

New Users:

Existing Users:

E-Mail:
Password:
Forgot Password?
Please enter the e-mail address or domain name you registered with:
E-Mail/Domain:
Back to Login
Log Out
  • Top News
  • Local News
  • World
  • U.S.
  • Sports
  • Politics
  • Tech
  • Entertainment
  • Science
  • Business
  • Health
  • Odd News
  • More
    • Arts
    • Education
    • Environment
    • Fashion
    • History
    • Home & Garden
    • Not News
    • Religion
    • Travel
What is Newsvine?

Updated continuously by citizens like you, Newsvine is an instant reflection of what the world is talking about at any given moment.

Get a Free Account
Help
Fun Stuff
  • Your Clippings
  • Leaderboard
  • E-Mail Alerts
  • Top of the Vine
  • Newsvine Live
  • Newsvine Archives
  • The Greenhouse
  • Recommended Articles
  • Wall of Vineness
Put a Seed Newsvine link on your own site

Boy Photoshops girl: A Flickr love story

Fri Feb 13, 2009 9:05 AM EST
business, internet, only-on-msnbc-com, aaron, skype, flickr, technotica, rosie, aaron-nace, arf, rosie-hardy
msnbc.com News — Helen A.S. Popkin, msnbc.com - Only on msnbc.com

Flickr

— Rosie Hardy and Aaron Nace are together for Valentine’s Day, which no doubt thrills their Flickr fans who’ve been following the couple’s 9 ½-month relationship via the photo-sharing Web site almost since the beginning.

It’s the photos of the couple together that have enchanted a growing number of soft-hearted saps across the Internet because Rosie, 18, and Aaron, 24, are almost never in the same room when the photos are taken. They’re not even in the same country. Rosie lives in Buxton, England, and Aaron in Chapel Hill, N.C. The photographers met on Flickr, and thanks to image-manipulating software, they’ve created a growing collection of wistful, fairytale illusions in which they are together.

At least, if that’s what you want to believe. As the cheer section that makes up the majority of comments on the couple’s photo blog demonstrates, plenty of people do. As the nastier comments on Rosie and Aaron fan blog entries reveal, there are those jaded, cynical haters who don’t buy much of what we see online, this relationship least of all. The collision of fates that make their love story is too preposterous. The couple is too ridiculously attractive. The highly stylized photographs are far too polished and professional. On the Internet, nobody knows you’re a dog.

A couple of things are certain: Rosie and Aaron are (physically) together on Feb. 11, and they’re certainly, neither of them, dogs. Technotica confirmed this via a video Skype call to (um … allegedly?) Rosie’s home in Buxton, where she lives with her parents and Aaron is visiting until Feb. 22.

“Internet hug!” says Rosie as she stretches her arms and leans toward the Web cam to show me how she greets Aaron on Skype when the two are an ocean apart. And St. Valentine help me, it’s more than this jaded, cynical hater can do than to resist her adorable smile and British accent, and Internet-hug her back.

Our Skype interview starts a bit later than planned because the couple say they'd just finished up a long photo shoot and needed time to clean up. Fantasy and theatrical make-up are a recurring theme in Aaron and Rosie's collaborative and solo work, and for this particular session, Rosie’s face was painted blue, “like a Smurf,” she says.  The couple huddles together in front of the computer camera in the poorly lit guest room.

Watching them via Skype, it seems this couple has the talent, yet none of the cool-kid affectation. The two blurt their plans to be together in July, when Rosie finishes college and moves to North Carolina. Once together, they’ll continue to expand their business enterprise, ARF (Aaron and Rosie Fotography) which already does a respectable trade retouching images, selling original photos and doing client shoots.

Though engagement isn’t yet an announcement, Rosie thrusts her “promise ring” from Aaron into the camera, a gold-and-diamond number with a second stone the color of “blurple,” her favorite imaginary shade. Then it’s down to brass tacks: A review of the legend of their unlikely meeting.

“We count our anniversary as the day we met,” Rosie says, the effusive half of the pair. “That was April 29.” Aaron nods along with a half-smile behind his hipster beard, filling in story gaps when prodded by his peppier half. April 29 is the day they first saw each other on Flickr.

Rosie, a photo-sharing newbie, was 12 days into her "365 Days,” a community Flickr project in which participants take and upload one self-portrait a day. That’s when a friend showed Rosie photos from another participant’s set (Aaron’s) that were remarkably like her own — playful images in which both seemed to be dining on a foot or twisting their faces in similar goofy expressions.

Rosie set out for home, with every intention of contacting this other photographer who’d been on Flickr for several years, only to find that by the time she logged on to her account, Aaron had e-mailed her first. “It was pretty weird,” says Aaron, agreeing on the kismet. “We both get a lot of people who contact us (via Flickr) so for that to happen is really unlikely.”

Unlikely ... but true?
From there, the relationship follows a storyline not unlike many Internet infatuations. Their communications grew longer, and more intense. Attempts by Rosie to get Aaron to open up, “like girls do,” Rosie says, resulted in a kind of extended fan fiction to each other, both taking turns adding written chapters to their hypothetical first date. The stories were personal, but increasingly Aaron and Rosie crowed about each other on their mutual blogs until Flickr compatriots suggested a photo of the two together. Thus began “Compilation Sundays.”

According to the couple, each photo in the “Compilation Sundays” set begins with an agreed-upon theme or idea. Rosie takes her self-portrait, then e-mails it to Aaron, who, using his sophisticated lighting equipment to match Rosie’s natural lighting, takes his self-portrait.

Aaron then spends the next five or so hours manipulating the two images into one photograph before uploading it to Flickr for Rosie and their fans to see. The first of the set is fairly simple compared to the increasingly detailed and fantastical images to come; just the two back-to-back, separated by the wall on which they lean.

“To everyone who suggested we do a shoot together, I love you,” Aaron wrote under this first image. “Today is the happiest day of my life. One step closer to us being together.”

Comments are equally effluvious. “Damn, this is awesome,” writes one of 147 commenters. “Hope it works out for you two. Would somebody buy an airline ticket for one of these two?”

“I can't believe this it is so gorgeous!” writes another. “Bless the two of you! Aaron you need a sooner flight mate!”

Soon after that first compilation, just 75 days after their first “meeting” (albeit an eternity to young lovers) Aaron and Rosie say they were finally together for the first time. Aaron took a flight to England. He was greeted at the airport by Rosie and her parents who — according to the couple — were long since convinced of Aaron’s good intentions by the e-mails and videos he made to show them he meant their daughter no ill.

Hanging doubts that this pair is a fabrication — actors manipulated by an outside hand looking to start some sort of viral campaign or get a movie deal a la lonelygirl15 — are quickly dissipated by Aaron’s long, detailed, and well … somewhat tedious nerd-speak descriptions of Photoshop techniques. When asked for positive ID, they flash their driver's licenses in front of the Skype cam without a moment’s hesitation.

When grilled about the sophistication of even Rosie’s earliest work, they extol the ease of GNU Image Manipulation Program (GIMP), Rosie’s preferred photo manipulation software, and delineate the many hours of their mutual lives spent before the computer in labor of their craft.

When pushed further as to whether they are really, truly, who they say they are, Rosie’s giggles and Aaron’s pinched brow seem to telegraph a lack of understanding as to what result anyone would want to fake their circumstances. Aaron especially seems interested in getting the ARF name out there, but then again, this is how he pays the rent. But there’s no PayPal button next to any ARF images, no overt sales pitch near any of their photos. When it comes to the question of selling their story as a screenplay, Rosie seems honestly perplexed as to why anyone would want to buy it.

Here’s the thing. These apparently guileless kids are sitting on an online empire and don’t seem to know it. Their fans create ARF T-shirts because Aaron and Rosie are so beloved by Internet romantics, bolstered by the idea that this fairytale might be possible for them. And yet, when asked about their fans, Rosie and Aaron talk about how, on bad or sad days, it’s nice to read the comments because it makes them feel better. SHUT UP!

Is this what we’ve come to, fellow jaded cynical haters? Is it so hard to fathom that this attractive couple have both a cross-continental fairytale love story as well as an eye for photo framing? Who did this to us? Usman Abdualhi, Chairman of Financial Aid in Nigeria? Was it lonelygirl15? Too many “Hallmark Holidays” spent alone in front of the A&E watching “Law & Order” marathons? (Or is that just me?)

Why is it so hard to believe that there are corners of the Internet where no one wants to exploit you sexually or steal your identity?

There are empirical truths about the Internet and humanity in general. People hook up on the Internet, all the time, even on Flickr. It is far from impossible that teenage girls and intense, nerdy guys fall easily and intensely in love and 100 percent believe the validity of their fantasy?

We can talk about the illusion of the Internet, the illusions Aaron and Rosie intentionally create in their images, courtship on the Internet as performance and blah blah blah. But it seems highly doubtful that Rosie and Aaron are in on this conversation, and neither are their fans.

  • Enjoy this article? Help vote it up the 'Vine.

Back To Top | Front Page

Published to:

  • Helen A.S. Popkin's Column, All of Newsvine
  • Groups: none
  • Regions: none
  • Public Discussion (56)
Jump to discussion page: 1 2
yomomma-778023

If nothing else, the photos are amazing.

  • 1 vote
Reply#1 - Fri Feb 13, 2009 11:38 AM EST
hugh-269915

My daughter met her husband in an online forum.

They became friends, had long conversations, exchanged photos, called each other on the phone (at great expense) and went on web cam.

There's not much more chance of being fooled that way than there is in a series of "real life" encounters.

They have been happily married for four years now.

    Reply#2 - Fri Feb 13, 2009 12:25 PM EST
    Chaychayolei

    I found Rosie's pics while surfing on Flickr about a month ago. The images are amazing and their love story is just beautiful.

    I met my husband online and we've been together for over 4 wonderful years. You CAN find love online!

    Congrats on the article Rosie. I'm rooting for you and Aaron! =)

      #2.1 - Fri Feb 13, 2009 2:28 PM EST
      Reply
      Joshua Kepler

      My story beats theirs by far. I found a girl on MySpace from Mexico while I was in the Air Force and she just happened to be moving to Ohio (my home state) for an Au Pair program. I was in Missouri at the time. We continued talking online and on the phone for months. Eventually she went back to Mexico. We continued talking online and doing webcam and occasionally by phone. We had many signs that led us to believe we were meant to be. She found a street in her city (Guadalajara) with my last name on it. Kepler is not a common last name either. She found a piece of paper that just fell in front of her feet that had my first name on it. There were several other signs that I can't even remember now. Anyways I ended up going to Mexico to meet her and now she is here in the US as a permanent resident. We have a beautiful baby boy and are happily married. I'm now in the Army.

      In total we talked for about a year and a half before we finally met each other in person, and now we have been married just over a year.

        Reply#3 - Fri Feb 13, 2009 12:51 PM EST
        1txlady

        Kudos to you both!

          #3.1 - Sat Feb 14, 2009 2:56 AM EST
          Reply
          uaskigyrl

          My boyfriend and I met on the internet when he was in deployed with the Army in Iraq and I was in the states.  We exchanged emails and instant messages for 3 years before we met in person.

            Reply#4 - Fri Feb 13, 2009 1:33 PM EST
            Adam-886967

            Dear Helen,

            I'm a journalist too.

            Did you knew that :

            1 - Rosie Hardy's story is as fake as lonelygirl15 ?
            2 - That it is not her who takes her photos ?
            2 - That she copies other photographers ideas and don't give then credit ?

            Rosie Hardy finds her ”inspiration” on the website DeviantART:

            You can see her DeviantART favourites here :

            PS : I hope that with all this information i will help you to find out the true story.

            • 1 vote
            Reply#5 - Fri Feb 13, 2009 2:27 PM EST
            Jaimie L

            Wow. If you're a journalist, I feel sorry for the person who edits your work. I also hope your articles provide some kind of evidence to support your given facts, as you have not given any evidence here.

            • 1 vote
            #5.1 - Sun Feb 15, 2009 12:24 AM EST
            Mark-889710

            Agreed. When it comes to research, your terrible. My wife and I personally know these two and the story is more real than your journalistic talents. Goto Flickr and join the "Raleigh Social Group" to read all you want about them. If you read any of the captions in Rosie or Aaron's photos they give credit to every photographer they are attempting to style their photos after. They both are extremely talented in their own rights, and don't need to justify their work to anyone.

              #5.2 - Sun Feb 15, 2009 3:10 PM EST
              Reply
              emily95

              I have a problem with the fact that no one had a problem from the beginning that this girl was only 17 and he was 24 when she came to the U.S. to meet him. In the real world, I would call that a child molester. There was never any intent to hide the fact they were in bed together from the first meeting....they posted photos of it!

              BTW, there is no sales pitch or paypal button near their photos because it is forbidden on the Flickr.

                Reply#6 - Fri Feb 13, 2009 2:29 PM EST
                sleeping tonight

                From my understanding, in England, 17 is not that big a deal. It is, fairly normal to begin relationships at young ages.

                • 1 vote
                #6.1 - Sat Feb 14, 2009 10:14 PM EST
                Reply
                Chaychayolei

                Emily, they have their own website to promote their company and services. This is what Helen was referring to when she said there is no paypal button.

                  Reply#7 - Fri Feb 13, 2009 2:35 PM EST
                  Adam-886967

                  I would like to know how do they find the time to :

                  - take one photo everyday,
                  - have an original idea everyday,
                  - Find a location
                  - The clothes
                  - The objects,
                  - Do the post-processing

                  Don't they work, study, sleep ?

                  Or maybe they have 11 assistants like Annie Leibovitz to help them ?

                  • 1 vote
                  Reply#8 - Fri Feb 13, 2009 2:50 PM EST
                  Geoffrey -887128

                  I think that their story is fake because mine is fake too.

                  I also have a Flickr account and i tell everybody that i do all the work, but it’s a lie.

                  I get help from my girlfriend who is a graphic designer. She retouch my images in Photoshop.

                  I also get help from my brother and my cousin who are professional photographers.

                  It is impossible that they do all the work by themselves. Specially the girl who’s been taking photos for less than a year.

                  Ask any proffessional photographer or retoucher.

                  PS : I think that their goal is to sell their story.

                  Who exposes their private lives on the Internet like that if they don’t want publicity ?

                  And all this « haters » stuff is good for them.

                  I would not be surprised if they were the « haters » so people would talk more and more about their story. It’s an excellent marketing tool.

                  I'm sure that they will sell thair story, i would not worry about that.

                    Reply#9 - Fri Feb 13, 2009 3:40 PM EST
                    Geoffrey -887128

                    I think that their story is fake because mine is fake too.

                    I also have a Flickr account and i tell everybody that i do all the work, but it’s a lie.

                    I get help from my girlfriend who is a graphic designer. She retouch my images in Photoshop.

                    I also get help from my brother and my cousin who are professional photographers.

                    It is impossible that they do all the work by themselves. Specially the girl who’s been taking photos for less than a year.

                    I'm sure that they are REAL, they only get help from professionals.

                    Ask any proffessional photographer or retoucher.

                    PS : I think that their goal is to sell their story.

                    Who exposes their private lives on the Internet like that if they don’t want publicity ?

                    And all this « haters » stuff is good for them.

                    It’s an excellent marketing tool.

                    I think that i will copy their idea.

                      Reply#10 - Fri Feb 13, 2009 3:59 PM EST
                      Geoffrey -887128

                      Do you remember The Cottingley Fairies case and how even Sir Arthur Conan Doyle believed their story ?

                      The Cottingley Fairies are a series of five photographs taken by Elsie Wright and Frances Griffiths, two young cousins living in Cottingley, near Bradford, in England depicting the two in various activities with supposed fairies.

                      In 1917, when the first two photos were taken, Elsie was 16 years old and Frances was 9. In 1981 the two women admitted to faking all but one of the photographs, but insisted that they really had seen fairies.

                        Reply#11 - Fri Feb 13, 2009 4:11 PM EST
                        Hot-in-Miami

                        Sounds like a nice story, though I haven't seen the site. Great idea for a movie though, you must admit!

                          Reply#12 - Fri Feb 13, 2009 4:40 PM EST
                          Rich in NJ

                          and if it's fake? who cares? bravo to them for the idea and I hope they sell it for a LOT of money!!!

                            Reply#13 - Fri Feb 13, 2009 4:55 PM EST
                            lux-777636

                            clearly this 16 year old british chick whos been taking photos for a year (supposedly) is getting them retouched by her tool hipster bf. hes really not that good either. not to mention if youve seen them they look EARILY alike.

                              Reply#14 - Fri Feb 13, 2009 5:49 PM EST
                              HighHorizon

                              lol, i was wondering about that myself (about them looking oddly alike)...

                              The whole story sounds kind of fakey to me.....but interesting photos anyways.

                                #14.1 - Fri Feb 13, 2009 9:15 PM EST
                                Reply
                                lux-777636

                                eerily* lolz

                                  Reply#15 - Fri Feb 13, 2009 5:50 PM EST
                                  Roxya

                                  What's so unbelievable about this?

                                  My husband and I met online through a shared hobby, in our case it involved gaming ;)
                                  He's from the UK and I'm from the US. We've been happily married since 2006.

                                  • 1 vote
                                  Reply#16 - Fri Feb 13, 2009 11:21 PM EST
                                  Valerie-565554

                                  I am a Flickr member and have had Aaron as a contact for some time now. I love what he can create with his camera and Photoshop. He is a great teacher as well as a great inspiration. He and Rosie make a very good team and a lovely couple.

                                  With all the bad things happening in the world right now it's nice to be able to be a part of this beautiful love story.

                                  Best wishes!!

                                    Reply#17 - Fri Feb 13, 2009 11:47 PM EST
                                    Dano-417914

                                    Good luck if they can make it work.... 99% of the stuff on the net is Crap, rip off and B.S.

                                    But the other 1% is the real deal... Good luck.........

                                      Reply#18 - Sat Feb 14, 2009 12:02 AM EST
                                      Tara-887982

                                      I adore Rosie and Aaron's photos. I found them on Flickr several months ago.

                                      I also believe the story to be *possible*, as I have had very real relationships begin online as well.

                                      However, as a photographer myself, I have to admit I have laways found it perplexing as to how Rosie, in particular, has the time to do these intricate photo shoots daily as well as the post-processing and also go to school, do papers, talk to Aaron, etc. I know how time consuming all of that is!

                                      They seme adorable and I always look forward to each new photo, by Rosie especially. If they are real, I wish them the best of luck.

                                        Reply#19 - Sat Feb 14, 2009 12:33 AM EST
                                        Sharon-790308

                                        I, too, think they look like brother and sister. Negative comments aside, the photography is phenomenal! I wish them luck professionally and personally! Oh, I should wish to manipulate Photoshop like that!

                                          Reply#20 - Sat Feb 14, 2009 12:37 AM EST
                                          Malcolm-887996

                                          This whole fiasco is about as bad as the stupid shows you see on tv preaching that only the rich and beautiful deserve to be happy. If these two people were fat and/or ugly, no one would give a damn about their little love story. There are millions of other people in this world who have formed lasting relationships after meeting online, but just because they don't look like the people that people want to see on tv every night they're success stories are rarely ever exposed to the public at large. This who thing wreaks of an unplanned publicity stunt. If I sound harsh then oh well. I just get so sick of the American public clammering to jump on the bandwagon of a situation involving anyone who looks good and allows them to vicariously live out the fantasy of a better life. As if we're not bombarded with enough bullcrap celebrity news on a daily basis.

                                            Reply#21 - Sat Feb 14, 2009 12:48 AM EST
                                            kaikisuka

                                            To be honest, I'd give more of a damn about it if they looked less like models.

                                            • 1 vote
                                            #21.1 - Sat Feb 14, 2009 6:13 PM EST
                                            Reply
                                            russ-888

                                            I know of another one which happened over youtube. a Welsh guy named Byron has effects69 channel and met a girl named Aleisha from the USA. They met over youtube and fell in love. They even made music videos together across the sea.

                                              Reply#22 - Sat Feb 14, 2009 1:47 AM EST
                                              sleeping tonight

                                              That's awesome. I wish I knew more about their story, too... It's not that they met online and fell in love. It's that they're meeting online, in a public forum, using their seperate talents to make something beautiful. It amazes me.

                                                #22.1 - Sat Feb 14, 2009 10:20 PM EST
                                                effects69

                                                We got married on the 7th of June this year :)

                                                  #22.2 - Thu Jun 25, 2009 12:08 PM EDT
                                                  Reply
                                                  1txlady

                                                  Real online romance happens! Whether R & A's is the real deal or hype for publicity, time will tell. I'd also keep in mind they're both quite young in years. The reverse horror stories do as well...but horror stories also happen every day in every city in every age group ... in the next block, at the local bar, through work, or using the local dating services.

                                                  Just because a connection began on Flickr, Facebook, Myspace or some chat program, doesn't mean it isn't a real connection. Fakes will always prey on the weak and needy no matter what medium they met. Real people will always gravitate to real as well. Smart people operate with eyes wide open and healthy skepticism while giving time a chance to produce reality...what is real versus what is not.

                                                  On the personal front, I've been on the net since it's inception in some form professionally and personally, in select chat programs. I personally know several success stories of love found on the net from afar (states or countries or continents) where couples (an immediate 8 couples come to mind in only the recent 3 years but I know many others). I also know of horror stories as well.

                                                  When I say successful relationships, I mean ones that have endured the miles until the miles no longer existed and culminated in very happy, fulfilling unions of marriage of 5 or more years now. For the distance itself not to be a deal killer, both people have to be on the same page in expectations and stability of the relationship. Both have to be cognizant of the effects of distance itself and eventually set timeframes to eliminate that distance. Control has to be a non entity and replaced by common desires.

                                                  The key to success in an online beginning is honesty...a wary honesty at that in the beginning. I have found personally that there can be as many games played in your own locale as there can be online. It boils down to two honest people hooking up who desire to share themselves over time in an honest fashion... who they are.. not who they or someone else wants them to be...and .....open communication is critical about real life, hopes, dreams, successes, failures, hurts, etc. IF that honesty exists on both sides, one can often learn more about another person through daily real communication whether it be online text, phone conversations, real pictures not dated ones, and skype type services or cam than you can dating someone a couple of times a week. When you're not in crowds of people doing things..movies, parties, business functions, sporting events, etc... you actually spend more real time learning who the other person is and sharing of oneself.

                                                  I've been involved online with someone for 10 months. We live 1700 miles apart. We are both single, mature adults in our early 50's. I have a more than rigorous and irradic work schedule. We've each our own businesses, families, and are very responsible adults with feet firmly planted on the ground. As a couple who met online, we've had our ups and downs as any couple "dating" would...the innate thing that propels all people in any relationship either to the next phase or .. call it quits. We have weathered those storms through communication ... daily communication.

                                                  We purposely chose not to meet in person too soon. We chose to get to know one another through writing, talking, sharing and living through some life and it's been peppered with some tough life experiences from work to health to families. We've supported each other in those. We stood by each other in those as we would have if we lived in the same state, city, town or block. None of those life experiences, by the way, included divorce because we've both been divorced for many years.

                                                  The beauty of it all is, we are and will be friends because that is from where our journey began without expectations. We are kindred spirits, respect ourselves and each other as people and our interests intertwine yet we each bring our own differences to this beautiful, caring relationship.

                                                  We're about a 6 weeks behind R & A in meeting face to face but we both know there are no surprises to overcome. Will the chemistry be there or not is the final test...if it is... then I will be one very lucky lady to have lived my "fairytale romance" complete with love letters from the soul of the most beautiful man I have ever known in my life...full of heart...a passionate soul that burns deeply.

                                                  I understand skepticism because I am a born cynic... even jaded by what I have watched occur on-line over the years in the stories that many have read about in the news or hear about from their friends. I've seen it occur more close. I've known some of the horror stories just as I know the successes. HOWEVER..... the successes happen... the real romance.. the real life unions... the real love ... and the real life successes.

                                                  If R &A's is the real deal, then I wish them well and say "cheers". If it's a way to promote their work, then so be it. They still came together then for a reason...maybe not for the lifetime romance...maybe for professional profit...maybe for both!

                                                  Positive begets positive ... let them have their moment... let them evolve to where it takes them. All journeys in this life are for a reason... we just don't always know at the time what the reason is.

                                                  What I know is, when he gets off that plane... we'll both know...the chemistry will either be there or not... we know we have the other ingredients for a happy, healthy, loving relationship... but what will the brain say?

                                                  Smiles....I feel it's going to be a very good year for wine...and roses.

                                                  Oh ... and ... I gave up rose colored glasses when I raised 3 teenage girls into respectable adulthood as a single mother...for the record.

                                                    Reply#23 - Sat Feb 14, 2009 2:44 AM EST
                                                    Lewis-888485

                                                    Of course these two are real people and that they showed you their ID.

                                                    But the point here is not to know if their identity is fake.

                                                    PEOPLE WANT TO KNOW WHO TAKE THE PHOTOS AND DOES THE RETOUCHING.

                                                    One thing is sure, they are helped by professional photographers and retouchers.

                                                    Rosie’s photos (even the first one’s) are too perfect, for an amateur photographer.

                                                    I have a friend who is a professional retoucher (since Photoshop’s First version) and i showed her Rosie’s photos. She told me that Rosie could NOT DO THE WORK WITHOUT THE HELP OF A PROFESSIONAL.

                                                    Miss Aniela who is a Flickr member since the begining doesn’t have the time to take one photo a day and she spend days retouching an image !

                                                    And Miss Aniela has more experience in Photography and Retouching than Rosie who has been taking photos for less than a year !

                                                    When Rosie began uploading her first photos (and the fairy tale series) she was a FULL TIME STUDENT and a PART TIME WAITRESS.

                                                    So where did she found the time to take the photos and do the retouching everyday ?

                                                      Reply#24 - Sat Feb 14, 2009 11:17 AM EST
                                                      sleeping tonight

                                                      I have a friend, she's married, works full-time, raises her two children (her and her husband work different shifts and seldom have a sitter), reads several books a week(and writes book reviews for a local publication) writes novels, searched for an editor/manager and just recently got published. I have no idea how she does it. My best guess is she doesn't sleep but she swears she finds time for that too.

                                                        #24.1 - Sat Feb 14, 2009 10:24 PM EST
                                                        Reply
                                                        emily95

                                                        While reading through their sites, I find it just a bit offensive that on one hand, they are begging their fans to buy their prints for plane tickets, and on the other Aaron has a collection of expensive cameras, including a recently purchased Canon EOS 5D Mark ll which retails around $3,000. I was also offended by a photo in his "stereotypes" set which mocks a homeless man. These people are clueless and so are their fans.

                                                          Reply#25 - Sat Feb 14, 2009 12:30 PM EST
                                                          Jump to discussion page: 1 2
                                                          Leave a Comment:
                                                          You're in Easy Mode. If you prefer, you can use XHTML Mode instead.
                                                          You're in XHTML Mode. If you prefer, you can use Easy Mode instead.
                                                          (XHTML tags allowed - a,b,blockquote,br,code,dd,dl,dt,del,em,h2,h3,h4,i,ins,li,ol,p,pre,q,strong,ul)
                                                          Newsvine Privacy Statement
                                                          As a new user, you may notice a few temporary content restrictions. Click here for more info.
                                                          FUN STUFF:
                                                          • Leaderboard |
                                                          • E-Mail Alerts |
                                                          • Top of the Vine |
                                                          • Newsvine Live |
                                                          • Newsvine Archives |
                                                          • The Greenhouse
                                                          COMPANY STUFF:
                                                          • Code of Honor |
                                                          • Company Info |
                                                          • Contact Us |
                                                          • Jobs |
                                                          • User Agreement |
                                                          • Privacy Policy |
                                                          • About our ads
                                                          LEGAL STUFF:
                                                          • © 2005-2012 Newsvine, Inc. |
                                                          • Newsvine® is a registered trademark of Newsvine, Inc. |
                                                          • Newsvine is a property of msnbc.com