Newsvine
  • Welcome
  • Help
  • Report Bug
  • Conversation Tracker
  • Your Column
  • Replies
  • Friends
Type Comments Since You Last CheckedArticle Source Last Checked Stop Tracking All Clear Tracking All
Advertise | AdChoices
Log In | Register
Close the Login Panel
Existing users log in below. New users please register for a free account.

New Users:

Existing Users:

E-Mail:
Password:
Forgot Password?
Please enter the e-mail address or domain name you registered with:
E-Mail/Domain:
Back to Login
Log Out
  • Top News
  • Local News
  • World
  • U.S.
  • Sports
  • Politics
  • Tech
  • Entertainment
  • Science
  • Business
  • Health
  • Odd News
  • More
    • Arts
    • Education
    • Environment
    • Fashion
    • History
    • Home & Garden
    • Not News
    • Religion
    • Travel
What is Newsvine?

Updated continuously by citizens like you, Newsvine is an instant reflection of what the world is talking about at any given moment.

Get a Free Account
Help
Fun Stuff
  • Your Clippings
  • Leaderboard
  • E-Mail Alerts
  • Top of the Vine
  • Newsvine Live
  • Newsvine Archives
  • The Greenhouse
  • Recommended Articles
  • Wall of Vineness
Put a Seed Newsvine link on your own site

Stodgy ‘Amelia’ never gets off the ground

Thu Oct 22, 2009 3:01 PM EDT
people, only-on-msnbc-com, movie, her, at-the-movies, amelia, amelia-earhart, swank, katharine-hepburn, gene-vidal
msnbc.com News — Alonso Duralde, msnbc.com - Only on msnbc.com

Hilary Swank plays Earhart, a noted American aviation pioneer, author and women's rights advocate who disappeared over the central Pacific Ocean near Howland Island during an attempt to make a circumnavigational flight of the globe in 1937.

Advertise | AdChoices

— The great women of the 20th century deserve better than what they’ve been getting from 21st century female filmmakers.

Anne Fontaine’s recent “Coco Before Chanel” seemed more interested in the legendary designer’s romantic exploits than in her boldness of vision, and now Mira Nair’s “Amelia” drains the life out of trailblazing aviator Amelia Earhart in a movie that feels like an afterschool special about a great American.

Hilary Swank — trying desperately to sound like Katharine Hepburn in “Christopher Strong” but sounding like she’s just struggling with her prosthetic teeth — plays Earhart with all the freckle-faced, pants-wearing, short-haired gumption she can muster. The film uses Earhart’s 1937 attempt to circumnavigate the globe as its through-line, cutting to one flashback after another.

There’s not much discussion of what drove this pioneer to tackle the skies in an era where such pursuits were considered to be for men only; we see a 12-year-old Amelia look wide-eyed as a vintage prop plane takes flight, and then bam, there’s Swank soaring among the clouds in a WWI biplane.

The aerial footage is breathtaking, whether Earhart is flying over the African veldt, a Kansas farm or the night skies over Washington. (Less successful are the shots from inside planes and cars; you can see the line around people’s heads in poorly-composited shots filmed in front of a green screen.)

Over the course of Earhart’s life, we see her fall in love with and marry publisher George Putnam (Richard Gere) and pursue an affair with aviation expert Gene Vidal (Ewan McGregor), who’s most famous these days as the father of author Gore Vidal.

Gere and McGregor are fine actors, but Nair uses them like the expendable males (Zachary Scott, Franchot Tone, et al) who stood back and let Bette Davis and Joan Crawford do all the heavy lifting back in the day.

Gere brings his trademark naughty twinkle to the role — with a dollop of Pepperidge Farm–flavored New England accent on top — but he and Swank have all the romantic chemistry of two people forced to share a table at a luncheonette during the noon rush.

Part of what made Amelia Earhart such a fascinating figure was how atypical she was for her time, but Nair doesn’t seem very interested in establishing any sort of context for her. We see one soup line, but that’s as much as the movie cares about the Great Depression, and there are very few times that anyone ever challenges Earhart on her flouting of the wife-and-mother paradigm of the era. It’s hard work standing up against societal expectations, but the movie pretends like Earhart’s flouting of convention and gender norms were just a walk in the park.

When Gene Vidal first meets Amelia, he’s amused by the native Kansan’s use of the word “hooey” in conversation. Judging by the final product, the writers of “Amelia” must have taped that word on the wall above their laptops, because this movie drips with it.

Follow msnbc.com Movie Critic Alonso Duralde at http://www.twitter.com/MSNBCalonso.

  • Enjoy this article? Help vote it up the 'Vine.

Back To Top | Front Page

Published to:

  • Alonso Duralde's Column, All of Newsvine
  • Groups: none
  • Regions: none
  • Public Discussion (11)
Lois-293362

Does this joker ever like anything that isn't animated.

    Reply#1 - Fri Oct 23, 2009 5:39 PM EDT
    newdoc17

    Haven't seen the movie yet, but I'm disappointed to hear that there is very little historical context. Without understanding her times, and the social expectations of that era, how could we even begin to understand the character?

      #1.1 - Sat Oct 24, 2009 4:09 PM EDT
      Reply
      Mark-730949

      Not even Wolverine, as he has the sides for it. Its ok he doesn't like movies, he is entertaining to read

        Reply#2 - Fri Oct 23, 2009 7:39 PM EDT
        debbie-1133361

        I am very disappointed in this review. I was really looking forward to this movie. I figured it couldn't miss with the subject matter of such a strong female heroine and such great stars. I think I'll go see it in spite of the review...the aerial shots should be great not to mention gazing at Richard Gere.

          Reply#3 - Fri Oct 23, 2009 10:11 PM EDT
          Anomalee23

          Straight to DVD Ha Ha Hilary..just what you deserve for thinking its ok to walk around nude in front of someone else's child. :) makes my day. And he said prosthetic teeth? I thought that would be her real teeth.

          • 1 vote
          #3.1 - Fri Oct 23, 2009 11:24 PM EDT
          Reply
          Waco Pilot

          Having just seen the movie -- I think he is a bit harsh that it doesn't get off the ground. The movie was well done... as a female pilot of a Waco biplane, I really enjoyed the movie (I hated that they used the new Waco Classic Biplanes instead of the original Wacos but not too many people would realize that).

          Regardless, he does have a point about the movie not making much of the fact that Amelia and every other lady pilot "back in the day" put up with a lot of grief pushing the edge of the envelope where society thought women should be. Sadly, even today, most people approach my husband about MY plane and start asking him questions never thinking that a woman would be flying it - despite my name being painted under the cockpit. But I am forever grateful and indebted to the women pilots of the 30's who kicked over the traces and fought for women to fly.

          Go see the movie -- it is good.

          • 2 votes
          Reply#4 - Fri Oct 23, 2009 11:14 PM EDT
          Anomalee23

          I'll pass but thanks Waco.

          • 1 vote
          #4.1 - Fri Oct 23, 2009 11:26 PM EDT
          newdoc17

          I'll see it, but am amazed that the director was so sloppy that an inauthentic plane was used! I'm also very annoyed to hear that the historical context of a woman's challenges at that time was glossed over, or ignored. Just like today...there is no such thing as discrimination anymore, right? (LOL!)

            #4.2 - Sat Oct 24, 2009 4:13 PM EDT
            Reply
            Nancy-1430133

            This movie was an incredible disappointment. I walked out of the theatre, saying to my sister - how could they take the life of someone so independent, so interesting, so far ahead of her time and only focus on her romance! Why not focus on her learning to fly, her driving forces, her forming the 99s, her interaction with Eleanor Roosevelt, her . . . . . Her life was CLEARLY not about romance - so why make a film built around it. UGH - - I was so looking forward to this film and sat in disbelief of what a mess they made of it.

            • 2 votes
            Reply#5 - Sat Oct 24, 2009 3:57 PM EDT
            newdoc17

            Sounds like a real movie about Amelia will need to be made in the future.

            • 1 vote
            Reply#6 - Sat Oct 24, 2009 4:14 PM EDT
            voiceinthewind

            Just got home from seeing Amelia. It was a boring movie. Very disappointing.

            • 1 vote
            Reply#7 - Sat Oct 24, 2009 11:25 PM EDT
            Leave a Comment:
            You're in Easy Mode. If you prefer, you can use XHTML Mode instead.
            You're in XHTML Mode. If you prefer, you can use Easy Mode instead.
            (XHTML tags allowed - a,b,blockquote,br,code,dd,dl,dt,del,em,h2,h3,h4,i,ins,li,ol,p,pre,q,strong,ul)
            Newsvine Privacy Statement
            As a new user, you may notice a few temporary content restrictions. Click here for more info.
            FUN STUFF:
            • Leaderboard |
            • E-Mail Alerts |
            • Top of the Vine |
            • Newsvine Live |
            • Newsvine Archives |
            • The Greenhouse
            COMPANY STUFF:
            • Code of Honor |
            • Company Info |
            • Contact Us |
            • Jobs |
            • User Agreement |
            • Privacy Policy |
            • About our ads
            LEGAL STUFF:
            • © 2005-2012 Newsvine, Inc. |
            • Newsvine® is a registered trademark of Newsvine, Inc. |
            • Newsvine is a property of msnbc.com