MSNBC Home
Newsvine Home
MSN Home
  • Conversation Tracker
  • Your Column
  • Replies
  • Friends
Type Comments Since You Last CheckedArticle Source Last Checked Stop Tracking All Clear Tracking All
advertisement
More tagged ,

Do you think Susan Boyle should have changed her look?

advertisement
Ready To Join?

Newsvine is msnbc.com's social-news community where you can discuss stories, publish your own column, and connect with other news lovers.

Results with 301 short comments
Total of 23,896 votes - click on the "Display Comments" bar below to sort comments

84.9%
Yes, if her true goal is to be a professional singer, she needed a makeover
20,299 votes
15.1%
No, her frumpy look was part of her "Britain's Got Talent" appeal
3,597 votes
Display Comments:
Yes, if her true goal is to be a professional singer, she needed a makeover

She's entitled to a new look which just enhanced what she had already...I would still listen to her songs. Let her have some joy!

{"commentId":6681719,"threadId":"562197","contentId":"2727865","authorDomain":"laulii"}
    #1
     - Sashaymistress
     - 11:38 am EDT on Fri Apr 24, 2009
    No, her frumpy look was part of her "Britain's Got Talent" appeal

    her homeliness had the effect of making her voice sound better than it actually is. Now she is no longer the singing frog.

    {"commentId":6681887,"threadId":"562197","contentId":"2727865","authorDomain":"vincent-deluca"}
      #2
       - Vince D-592170
       - 11:44 am EDT on Fri Apr 24, 2009
      Yes, if her true goal is to be a professional singer, she needed a makeover

      There were a lot of mean comments about her appearance. I think she is fine either way. She still looks very 'real'. I hope she wins.

      {"commentId":6681970,"threadId":"562197","contentId":"2727865","authorDomain":"linda-laforge"}
      • 13 votes
      #3
       - Linda L.-463514
       - 11:47 am EDT on Fri Apr 24, 2009
      Yes, if her true goal is to be a professional singer, she needed a makeover

      she didnt get a makeover. she just freshened up a bit to look more professional.

      {"commentId":6682023,"threadId":"562197","contentId":"2727865","authorDomain":"precioso2"}
      • 1 vote
      #4
       - pfm-1052427
       - 11:49 am EDT on Fri Apr 24, 2009
      Yes, if her true goal is to be a professional singer, she needed a makeover

      Oh, for pete's sake! She can do whatever she wants without getting permission first! She's a grown woman!

      {"commentId":6682025,"threadId":"562197","contentId":"2727865","authorDomain":"coaldancer"}
      • 10 votes
      #5
       - mageen
       - 11:49 am EDT on Fri Apr 24, 2009
      Yes, if her true goal is to be a professional singer, she needed a makeover

      Yes - she already made her splash as the frumpy singer, now she has to have a polished look to match that great voice!

      {"commentId":6682145,"threadId":"562197","contentId":"2727865","authorDomain":"weeble1216"}
      • 5 votes
      #6
       - donna-397871
       - 11:53 am EDT on Fri Apr 24, 2009
      Yes, if her true goal is to be a professional singer, she needed a makeover

      I guarantee it was her voice that won over everyone. She needs a new look to work in London's West End like she wants.

      {"commentId":6682273,"threadId":"562197","contentId":"2727865","authorDomain":"nlayer78"}
      • 4 votes
      #7
       - NicoleL
       - 11:57 am EDT on Fri Apr 24, 2009
      Yes, if her true goal is to be a professional singer, she needed a makeover

      What's wrong with a makeover? She looks good and she deserves it.

      {"commentId":6682283,"threadId":"562197","contentId":"2727865","authorDomain":"frwl31"}
        #8
         - frwl31
         - 11:57 am EDT on Fri Apr 24, 2009
        Yes, if her true goal is to be a professional singer, she needed a makeover

        She still has the natural beauty she possessed - it just shows more. I think she's just lovely

        {"commentId":6682285,"threadId":"562197","contentId":"2727865","authorDomain":"thenest"}
        • 8 votes
        #9
         - TheNest
         - 11:57 am EDT on Fri Apr 24, 2009
        Yes, if her true goal is to be a professional singer, she needed a makeover

        The changes she has made are just the right touch.

        {"commentId":6682308,"threadId":"562197","contentId":"2727865","authorDomain":"saintrita"}
        • 8 votes
        #10
         - Lois-293362
         - 11:58 am EDT on Fri Apr 24, 2009
        Yes, if her true goal is to be a professional singer, she needed a makeover

        I think she looks grand. And everyone can be made to look current. Why shouldn't she live the dream??

        {"commentId":6682327,"threadId":"562197","contentId":"2727865","authorDomain":"nlipson"}
          #11
           - Amber-1052463
           - 11:59 am EDT on Fri Apr 24, 2009
          Yes, if her true goal is to be a professional singer, she needed a makeover

          She got the chance and probably the money to improve her look. Why would anyone criticize her for doing it? Bravo!

          {"commentId":6682339,"threadId":"562197","contentId":"2727865","authorDomain":"yael-1"}
          • 3 votes
          #12
           - YLock111
           - 11:59 am EDT on Fri Apr 24, 2009
          Yes, if her true goal is to be a professional singer, she needed a makeover

          she now has the money and the interest in changing her look, that is her business! However, I would have a problem with plastic surgery.

          {"commentId":6682362,"threadId":"562197","contentId":"2727865","authorDomain":"galasgarden"}
            #13
             - AnnA-1052468
             - 12:00 pm EDT on Fri Apr 24, 2009
            Yes, if her true goal is to be a professional singer, she needed a makeover

            just leave her alone; if u dont like the art...stay away

            {"commentId":6682403,"threadId":"562197","contentId":"2727865","authorDomain":"astoriaguyitalo"}
            • 4 votes
            #14
             - sellingpencils
             - 12:01 pm EDT on Fri Apr 24, 2009
            Yes, if her true goal is to be a professional singer, she needed a makeover

            For God sake - cut the woman some slack - if it's what she wanted - let her be. Keep singing Susan.

            {"commentId":6682408,"threadId":"562197","contentId":"2727865","authorDomain":"pjaustin93010"}
            • 5 votes
            #15
             - PJ-547553
             - 12:02 pm EDT on Fri Apr 24, 2009
            Yes, if her true goal is to be a professional singer, she needed a makeover

            This is as far as she should go...she needs to pay attention to the millions who have blogged stating they love her old look !

            {"commentId":6682412,"threadId":"562197","contentId":"2727865","authorDomain":"EverybodysACritic"}
            • 3 votes
            #16
             - EverybodysACritic
             - 12:02 pm EDT on Fri Apr 24, 2009
            Yes, if her true goal is to be a professional singer, she needed a makeover

            I adore her regardless of how she looks.

            {"commentId":6682437,"threadId":"562197","contentId":"2727865","authorDomain":"jnickj6"}
            • 5 votes
            #17
             - JnickJ6
             - 12:03 pm EDT on Fri Apr 24, 2009
            Yes, if her true goal is to be a professional singer, she needed a makeover

            This really has nothing to do if she wants to be a professional singer. I say you go girl. I think she looks great.

            {"commentId":6682455,"threadId":"562197","contentId":"2727865","authorDomain":"Adpacqueen"}
            • 6 votes
            #18
             - Sharon-506809
             - 12:03 pm EDT on Fri Apr 24, 2009
            Yes, if her true goal is to be a professional singer, she needed a makeover

            She went just far enough. Susan needs to feel as pretty as she wants to. Beauty isn't hair design or eyebrows or anything of glamor.

            {"commentId":6682458,"threadId":"562197","contentId":"2727865","authorDomain":"danceswithdingos"}
            • 3 votes
            #19
             - Dances With Dingos-1000249
             - 12:03 pm EDT on Fri Apr 24, 2009
            Yes, if her true goal is to be a professional singer, she needed a makeover

            It should be up to her how far she wants to go, but if I were here I would just improve the things that bother me about myself.

            {"commentId":6682468,"threadId":"562197","contentId":"2727865","authorDomain":"iwriteonrice"}
            • 2 votes
            #20
             - Generation X'er
             - 12:03 pm EDT on Fri Apr 24, 2009
            No, her frumpy look was part of her "Britain's Got Talent" appeal

            DON'T TOUCH a hair on her head. she must feel comfortable in her own skin ... for us to feel comfortable with her.

            {"commentId":6682472,"threadId":"562197","contentId":"2727865","authorDomain":"irishmurph"}
            • 4 votes
            #21
             - mj-374644
             - 12:04 pm EDT on Fri Apr 24, 2009
            Yes, if her true goal is to be a professional singer, she needed a makeover

            Being well-groomed is good mental healthy; being frumpy is unhealthy. She is merely showing the joy that has come into her life

            {"commentId":6682473,"threadId":"562197","contentId":"2727865","authorDomain":"dlipper1"}
              #22
               - Nana-1052481
               - 12:04 pm EDT on Fri Apr 24, 2009
              Yes, if her true goal is to be a professional singer, she needed a makeover

              I'm sure it makes her feel good. This is a woman who has been ignored and overlooked her entire life. Maybe now she feels beautiful.

              {"commentId":6682480,"threadId":"562197","contentId":"2727865","authorDomain":"starrlite9212"}
              • 3 votes
              #23
               - starrlite9212
               - 12:04 pm EDT on Fri Apr 24, 2009
              Yes, if her true goal is to be a professional singer, she needed a makeover

              She just needed to look a bit more professional. I don't think the makeover was all that extreme.

              {"commentId":6682645,"threadId":"562197","contentId":"2727865","authorDomain":"lj-hend"}
              • 5 votes
              #24
               - LyndaAZ
               - 12:10 pm EDT on Fri Apr 24, 2009
              Yes, if her true goal is to be a professional singer, she needed a makeover

              a little 'cleanup' is always good, as long as she remains true to herself ... go for it !

              {"commentId":6682660,"threadId":"562197","contentId":"2727865","authorDomain":"DudeNorthoftheborder"}
              • 5 votes
              #25
               - Dude_North_Of_The_Border
               - 12:10 pm EDT on Fri Apr 24, 2009