MSNBC Home
Newsvine Home
MSN Home
  • Conversation Tracker
  • Your Column
  • Replies
  • Friends
Type Comments Since You Last CheckedArticle Source Last Checked Stop Tracking All Clear Tracking All
advertisement
More tagged

What's most important on 'American Idol'?

advertisement
Ready To Join?

Newsvine is msnbc.com's social-news community where you can discuss stories, publish your own column, and connect with other news lovers.

Results with 13 short comments
Total of 898 votes - click on the "Display Comments" bar below to sort comments

48%
Sheer performance, the best singer wins
431 votes
17%
You need to show improvement or the judges will get restless
153 votes
35%
It's all about popularity and personality. Teens vote for cute!
314 votes
Display Comments:
Sheer performance, the best singer wins

Adam should win!!!

{"commentId":6883363,"threadId":"570497","contentId":"2775448","authorDomain":"kg1273"}
  • 1 vote
#1
 - kgavit
 - 8:54 pm EDT on Mon May 4, 2009
You need to show improvement or the judges will get restless

Adam sucks....!!!!

{"commentId":6888850,"threadId":"570497","contentId":"2775448","authorDomain":"transdell1"}
  • 1 vote
#2
 - Troy-524369
 - 9:02 am EDT on Tue May 5, 2009
You need to show improvement or the judges will get restless

Objective of the show - FIND UNDISCOVERED TALENT!!!!! Stop letting the ones who have had a record label sign before. Reach for your dream

{"commentId":6888977,"threadId":"570497","contentId":"2775448","authorDomain":"beach88bum70"}
  • 2 votes
#3
 - Sherri-
 - 9:11 am EDT on Tue May 5, 2009
Sheer performance, the best singer wins

Adam will win for out-and-out talent, but he is NOT my favorite. All of the top 5 have careers ahead of them, they are that good.

{"commentId":6889213,"threadId":"570497","contentId":"2775448","authorDomain":"jeffEProv"}
    #4
     - Jeff from East Providence
     - 9:26 am EDT on Tue May 5, 2009
    Sheer performance, the best singer wins

    WE need to keep a showcase for fresh new talent, Go Adam!

    {"commentId":6889270,"threadId":"570497","contentId":"2775448","authorDomain":"penpat426"}
      #5
       - Pat-285361
       - 9:30 am EDT on Tue May 5, 2009
      Sheer performance, the best singer wins

      Style over substance seems to be the norm.

      {"commentId":6889484,"threadId":"570497","contentId":"2775448","authorDomain":"thisisthecat"}
        #6
         - JV Miller
         - 9:42 am EDT on Tue May 5, 2009
        It's all about popularity and personality. Teens vote for cute!

        Go Kris Allen!!!!!!!

        {"commentId":6890344,"threadId":"570497","contentId":"2775448","authorDomain":"bkk1233"}
          #7
           - bk-1081476
           - 10:24 am EDT on Tue May 5, 2009
          It's all about popularity and personality. Teens vote for cute!

          It SHOULD be sheer performance, but we all know it's really nothing more than a popularity contest.

          {"commentId":6899259,"threadId":"570497","contentId":"2775448","authorDomain":"hmw82"}
          • 1 vote
          #8
           - No diot
           - 5:11 pm EDT on Tue May 5, 2009
          It's all about popularity and personality. Teens vote for cute!

          As much as I hate to admit it, this is definitely the reason.

          {"commentId":6899524,"threadId":"570497","contentId":"2775448","authorDomain":"pfields"}
            #9
             - PFields
             - 5:26 pm EDT on Tue May 5, 2009
            You need to show improvement or the judges will get restless

            Both are ideal. David Cook is a good example. So it the original, super awesome Kelly Clarkson!

            {"commentId":6900305,"threadId":"570497","contentId":"2775448","authorDomain":"kgonz23"}
              #10
               - Bailey Quarters
               - 6:11 pm EDT on Tue May 5, 2009
              Sheer performance, the best singer wins

              the two kinda contradict themselves. you can have an amazing performance without being the best singer. its the performance that matters.

              {"commentId":6901738,"threadId":"570497","contentId":"2775448","authorDomain":"kcha295"}
                #11
                 - kcha295
                 - 7:42 pm EDT on Tue May 5, 2009
                It's all about popularity and personality. Teens vote for cute!

                I think the most important thing about Idol is that it not return nexr season!!

                {"commentId":7091942,"threadId":"570497","contentId":"2775448","authorDomain":"phobob"}
                  #12
                   - robbob
                   - 8:15 am EDT on Fri May 15, 2009
                  Sheer performance, the best singer wins

                  If you are a great perfomer from the beginning, you shouldn't be penalized! Adam has given consistent stellar performances! GO ADAM!!!!!!!

                  {"commentId":7095785,"threadId":"570497","contentId":"2775448","authorDomain":"weeble1216"}
                    #13
                     - donna-397871
                     - 11:03 am EDT on Fri May 15, 2009