Why not? It's not like anyone dominated!
Newsvine is msnbc.com's social-news community where you can discuss stories, publish your own column, and connect with other news lovers.
Results with 3 short comments
Total of 697 votes - click on the "Display Comments" bar below to sort comments
62.8%
Yes
438 votes
37.2%
No
259 votes
Display Comments:
Newsvine Discussion with 15 comments - Click here to jump to the comment form.
{"commentId":8222020,"authorDomain":"engleltc"}
Does a bear deficate in the woods?
{"commentId":8222020,"threadId":"626880","contentId":"3027008","authorDomain":"engleltc"}
#1 - Wed Jul 15, 2009 6:33 AM EDT{"commentId":8222533,"authorDomain":"gwest40"}
There wasn't much to chose from as far as an MVP performance, but I thought that Curtis Granderson's triple was an aggressive play that led to the go-ahead run. I think he should have been the MVP.
{"commentId":8222533,"threadId":"626880","contentId":"3027008","authorDomain":"gwest40"}
- 1 vote
#2 - Wed Jul 15, 2009 7:59 AM EDT{"commentId":8223298,"authorDomain":"paul-40"}
Whiile the catch was spectacular. Curtis Granderson's triple with his aggressive baserunning trumps the catch. CG should have been the MVP!
{"commentId":8223298,"threadId":"626880","contentId":"3027008","authorDomain":"paul-40"}
- 1 vote
{"commentId":8222627,"authorDomain":"zapain"}
Who cares? The game, home run derby and the softball classic are just an excuse to give the over paid prima donnas a few days off. And one play makes an MVP? If that's the case, I agree with Nissan that Granderson's triple was the most valuable play. It led to the winning run. Crawford's catch, however spectacular, only prevented the go ahead run. Isn't is usually the go ahead score that garners this award? Or the play that creates it? That's usually the case in the Superbowl. But hey, it's all subjective. They should've split the award between these two guys IMHO.
And the league that wins gets home field advantage is supposed to make the game more meaningful? Yah right.
They need to to that with the NBA all star game, then some of those guys might play some defense and the scores wouldn't be in the 120's or 130's. Instead, that game is full of matadors going "Ole" and letting their buddies fly by for a picturesque dunk. At least the NBA players are voted in by their peers. The MLB players are voted in by mass balloting idiots who put in the same players year after year no matter how well they've played throughout the season so far.
{"commentId":8222627,"threadId":"626880","contentId":"3027008","authorDomain":"zapain"}
#3 - Wed Jul 15, 2009 8:09 AM EDT{"commentId":8222826,"authorDomain":"brand3bkc"}
I wish there was one thing you said I could disagree with! Right on the money.
{"commentId":8222826,"threadId":"626880","contentId":"3027008","authorDomain":"brand3bkc"}
{"commentId":8222848,"authorDomain":"steviepittsley"}
It was a Nice Catch , But I think the Kid that hit the Triple Derserves to be MVP. He had to hustle it out to get to third, and then score what turned into the winning run .
The kid from Detriot got ripped off, because Crawford is more of a " household Name " , because he leads the world in stolen bases, He vastly over rated , and ofteb falters in the outside on a regular basis, but people who odn't follow AL East Baseball would never know that ....I guess what ever Joe Maddon says , Goes ... Since he had his " entire " team out there ...
A mistake was made, and the MVP should go to Granderson , period ....
{"commentId":8222848,"threadId":"626880","contentId":"3027008","authorDomain":"steviepittsley"}
- 1 vote
#4 - Wed Jul 15, 2009 8:31 AM EDT{"commentId":8225089,"authorDomain":"recabaniss"}
You must be a YANKEE fan...............or Boston. Still upset that the Rays knocked you both out last year.
{"commentId":8225089,"threadId":"626880","contentId":"3027008","authorDomain":"recabaniss"}
{"commentId":8228542,"authorDomain":"jcraig-1"}
Rick -- you're right -- he must be a Yankee or Red Sox fan. Obviously, I'm biased on this one but I think Crawford deserved it for the catch and a single. I also think Granderson just as easily could be MVP.
By the way, I don't think Maddon had anything to do with the MVP selection -- I believe it's the media. Although I think Steve speaks English I'm trying to understand what "ofteb falters in the outside on a regular basis." If he means Crawford falters in the outfield, he's smoking crack. Crawford has speed and range and makes catches that few others except maybe his teammate, B.J. Upton, can make. I've watched almost every Rays game this year and I don't know how you can say Crawford doesn't play well in the field. And yes, he does lead MLB in stolen bases.
{"commentId":8228542,"threadId":"626880","contentId":"3027008","authorDomain":"jcraig-1"}
{"commentId":8223959,"authorDomain":null}
Curtis Granderson should have been the MVP. Crawford made a nice catch, but the fence was only 8 feet high. If you're 6 feet tall, you can merely stand next to the fence and lift up your arm without jumping to catch the ball. If Granderson doesn't stretch a double into a triple, he doesn't score on a sacrifice fly and the National League could have won in extra innings. Like everything else about the All-Star Game, even the MVP selection has become a joke.
{"commentId":8224364,"authorDomain":"BigMike60"}
Late inning, potential game changer, reasonable choice. Plus he had a hit too didn't he?
{"commentId":8224364,"threadId":"626880","contentId":"3027008","authorDomain":"BigMike60"}
#6 - Wed Jul 15, 2009 10:15 AM EDT{"commentId":8225186,"authorDomain":"recabaniss"}
I agree with you Mike........It had the chance to change the outcome of the game. The NL might have won the game and broke the streak. Yes he did get a hit in his first at bat.....
They players on the winning team, AL all agreed it was the right choice....... Ask Pablebon... He was glad he made the catch....
{"commentId":8225186,"threadId":"626880","contentId":"3027008","authorDomain":"recabaniss"}
{"commentId":8225044,"authorDomain":"recabaniss"}
Yes, had he NOT made the catch the NL would have gone ahead and might have won the game......It SAVED the game for the AL..........He deserves the credit for the catch.
{"commentId":8225044,"threadId":"626880","contentId":"3027008","authorDomain":"recabaniss"}
#7 - Wed Jul 15, 2009 10:46 AM EDT{"commentId":8225717,"authorDomain":"ypsikids"}
Granderson should have won it.
{"commentId":8225717,"threadId":"626880","contentId":"3027008","authorDomain":"ypsikids"}
#8 - Wed Jul 15, 2009 11:12 AM EDT{"commentId":8226912,"authorDomain":"steve-1214182"}
It was an amazing catch - I love watching a guy bring back a homerun (unless it's against my team). It's exciting to see him put in that kind of effort in the game.
{"commentId":8226912,"threadId":"626880","contentId":"3027008","authorDomain":"steve-1214182"}
#9 - Wed Jul 15, 2009 11:58 AM EDT{"commentId":8232936,"authorDomain":"jawhy69"}
The catch is what won / ended the game. That was the best play (offensive or defensive).
{"commentId":8232936,"threadId":"626880","contentId":"3027008","authorDomain":"jawhy69"}
#10 - Wed Jul 15, 2009 3:29 PM EDT{"canLink":false,"threadId":"626880","isPrivate":false}
You're in Easy Mode. If you prefer, you can use XHTML Mode instead. |
As a new user, you may notice a few temporary content restrictions. Click here for more info.
It saved the game. He also got the hit that ultimately resulted in Jeter scoring.