NBC Sports

More news in NBCSports

What is the hardest thing to do in sports?

advertisement
Ready To Join?

Newsvine is msnbc.com's social-news community where you can discuss stories, publish your own column, and connect with other news lovers.

Ready To Join?

Results with 14 short comments
Total of 2,328 votes - click on the "Display Comments" bar below to sort comments

64.8%
Hit a baseball
1,509 votes
8.2%
Play quarterback
192 votes
1%
Shoot a basketball
23 votes
11.1%
Hit a golf ball
258 votes
8.2%
Stop a hockey puck
192 votes
6.6%
Handle a race car
154 votes
Display Comments:
Hit a baseball

I tried and I failed. Baseball is the hardest- the batter is on a stage when he bats.

{"commentId":10355859,"threadId":"711240","contentId":"3273462","authorDomain":"david-stever"}
  • 1 vote
 - 12:20 pm EDT on Thu Oct 29, 2009
Hit a baseball

Not only does the batter have to make contact, but overcome the spin and movement of the ball by a good pitcher. Tough job.

{"commentId":10374519,"threadId":"711240","contentId":"3273462","authorDomain":"bencas4"}
  • 1 vote
 - bencas
 - 11:06 am EDT on Fri Oct 30, 2009
Hit a golf ball

Just look at he physics of each sport and it is easy to figure out which one is the hardest. Break down each of those events its golf

{"commentId":10375428,"threadId":"711240","contentId":"3273462","authorDomain":"tesork"}
     - 11:41 am EDT on Fri Oct 30, 2009
    Handle a race car

    You can count on the fingers of your hands and toes (even if you are polydactyl) the number of people who can drive an F1 car.

    {"commentId":10392205,"threadId":"711240","contentId":"3273462","authorDomain":"leftcoastblue"}
       - 8:39 am EDT on Sat Oct 31, 2009
      Hit a baseball

      No contest, as long as you say 'hit a curveball.' Anyone can hit a golf ball, although hitting it straight every time is definitely #2.

      {"commentId":10403733,"threadId":"711240","contentId":"3273462","authorDomain":"stoddardwa"}
      • 1 vote
       - 12:01 am EDT on Sun Nov 1, 2009
      Hit a baseball

      Right after this would be the golf ball thing for sure.

      {"commentId":10408855,"threadId":"711240","contentId":"3273462","authorDomain":"luminator"}
      • 1 vote
       - 12:26 pm EST on Sun Nov 1, 2009
      Hit a baseball

      Not rocket science here. Swinging a bat at 100 mph in one direction trying to hit a baseball coming in at 90-95mph from the other.

      {"commentId":10466228,"threadId":"711240","contentId":"3273462","authorDomain":"kevpatok"}
      • 1 vote
       - 9:36 am EST on Wed Nov 4, 2009
      Hit a golf ball

      I've played all of these sports and have driven a car at high speed. Nothing compares to successfully hitting a golf ball.

      {"commentId":10478946,"threadId":"711240","contentId":"3273462","authorDomain":"karlm"}
         - 5:04 pm EST on Wed Nov 4, 2009
        Hit a baseball

        Are you kidding? Most would not even know the ball had whizzed by.

        {"commentId":10479005,"threadId":"711240","contentId":"3273462","authorDomain":"carolync-1"}
        • 1 vote
         - 5:07 pm EST on Wed Nov 4, 2009
        Hit a baseball

        I think hitting a baseball is the hardest sport. In my opinion, the hitter must have an excellent timing and eye to hit the ball.

        {"commentId":10479295,"threadId":"711240","contentId":"3273462","authorDomain":"Lalita9"}
        • 1 vote
         - Lalita$
         - 5:22 pm EST on Wed Nov 4, 2009
        Hit a baseball

        although I can do it, it takes timing, a lot of practice, and hand-eye coordination while all the others you can do right away!

        {"commentId":10480144,"threadId":"711240","contentId":"3273462","authorDomain":"dmonmcd"}
        • 1 vote
         - DMONMCD
         - 6:01 pm EST on Wed Nov 4, 2009
        Hit a baseball

        I love baseball. I have always admired the skill the players use to play the game.

        {"commentId":10480387,"threadId":"711240","contentId":"3273462","authorDomain":"campbell5584"}
        • 1 vote
         - AC55
         - 6:13 pm EST on Wed Nov 4, 2009
        Shoot a basketball

        Wouldn't really know for sure. I grew up years ago, so I don't do any of those anymore. Just grown up things

        {"commentId":10480773,"threadId":"711240","contentId":"3273462","authorDomain":"bartman10"}
           - 6:33 pm EST on Wed Nov 4, 2009
          Hit a baseball

          Hitting a baseball well is the hardest to do succesfully. Next is handling a race car. Then golf. Shoot a basketball? Hah! Easiest by far!

          {"commentId":10481924,"threadId":"711240","contentId":"3273462","authorDomain":"triberules"}
          • 1 vote
           - 7:34 pm EST on Wed Nov 4, 2009
          advertisement

          Newsvine Discussion with 44 comments - Click here to jump to the comment form.

          Jump to discussion page: 1 2
          {"commentId":10305093,"authorDomain":"george-3246"}

          This is the most bogus sports question that has been continually asked by American sports enthusiasts over the years. If only those five sports skills are included, what should be asked is " What is the hardest thing to do in sports that only dumbass Americans know about?"

          Even if the question provided qualifying criteria about the level of excellence expected or competition to be faced, it is still bogus. Ie.. hit a golf ball 300 yards with no slice or hook; hit a baseball thrown 95 mph or shoot a basketball from 25 feet with defensive pressure. In all truth, I'm surprised that Newsvine allowed such a shallow question to be posted.

          Having played, coached or conducted competitions in numerous sports over my lifetime, I know that there are many sports skills far more difficult than the above mentioned.

          There are sports that require a high level of conditioning to even compete. Anybody that ever wrestled at a high school or higher level can identify. The wide range of combat sports skills that could lead to competing in mixed martial arts require an incredible level of conditioning and skill. Think triathlon or the extreme sports that you see on the X Games.

          It would take too long for me to list other skills that I consider far more difficult that those in your question. Here are two examples: If you have never stood up on a surfboard to catch and ride a wave, you cannot begin to identify how hard that skill is. Likewise, if you haven't run at 3/4 speed up and down a soccer field for nearly a full game (six miles average), then trap a ball kicked to you from thirty yards away off your chest and then kick it it into the net twenty yards away, same thing. This last example will probably produce reactions from the intelligence challenged that will say that soccer is boring so it doesn't count. That is because the bozos would never understand how hard it is to create such an incredible play.

          BTW: Driving a car is not a sport.

          {"commentId":10305093,"threadId":"679137","contentId":"3273462","authorDomain":"george-3246"}
          • 1 vote
          Reply#1 - Tue Oct 27, 2009 2:07 AM EDT
          {"commentId":10305775,"authorDomain":"mroth"}

          Sorry George - you're on the right track, but you hit the rail...

          You are correct - race car driving is not a sport. We can classify those as "activities" - (been fighting this battle for years w/a friend who loves "darts"!)

          If you use your examples, then Bill Rogers or Lance Armstrong would be considered the world's greatest athletes. The question is not "which sport has the best conditioned athletes" - it was "which skill is hardest" - and we can define skill as a specific physical action required to excel in a particular sport.

          Soccer clearly has incredibly conditioned athletes. But to say chest trapping a cross-field pass & kicking it into a net in one move is the hardest skill in sport, you're sorely mistaken. How fast is that "very large" ball travelling? Not such a big deal...many can do it very well.

          Hitting a baseball is absolutely one of the hardest skills, as is stopping a point-blank slapshot. Hitting a golf ball where it is supposed to go, in the wind, 'aint exactly an easy task. Close behind are pitching - considering the object is to make the hitter miss - and passing in football - again, considering the object as to have your own receiver catch the ball.

          Your surfing example is a good one - requiring incomparable balance. Ask the figure skaters how easy a triple-axel is to perform without landing on your butt. Skiiers would be upset to be left off this list when discussing balance - but figure skating is harder - less surface area on blades than skis.

          But on the whole, the question is an age-old one that is certainly not bogus - it just needs proper definition. You've confused "skill" with "conditioning" in your analysis, so sorry. Go swim...

          (Any ballet dancers or gymnasts care to comment?)

          {"commentId":10305775,"threadId":"679137","contentId":"3273462","authorDomain":"mroth"}
          • 2 votes
          #1.1 - Tue Oct 27, 2009 4:13 AM EDT
          {"commentId":10392247,"authorDomain":"leftcoastblue"}

          Sorry, driving F1 IS a sport. Ever watched Top Gear? The hosts continually point out how punishing it is to get into a car that can go from 0-100mph in 3 seconds, pull Gs like a fighter pilot in the turns, and stop on the proverbial dime. For two hours.

          Golf?!?! Old cripples can play golf.

          {"commentId":10392247,"threadId":"679137","contentId":"3273462","authorDomain":"leftcoastblue"}
            #1.2 - Sat Oct 31, 2009 8:44 AM EDT
            {"commentId":10392620,"authorDomain":"rbass7"}

            dumbass Americans know about, and you are a ???? please tell us so we can put you on our shi* list

            {"commentId":10392620,"threadId":"679137","contentId":"3273462","authorDomain":"rbass7"}
            • 2 votes
            #1.3 - Sat Oct 31, 2009 9:16 AM EDT
            {"commentId":10479047,"authorDomain":"carolync-1"}

            Neither is riding a bull, fighting with a bull, or....boxing. Barbaric all

            {"commentId":10479047,"threadId":"679137","contentId":"3273462","authorDomain":"carolync-1"}
            • 1 vote
            #1.4 - Wed Nov 4, 2009 5:09 PM EST
            {"commentId":10481952,"authorDomain":"jls98001"}

            To answer your question you only have to look at middle 90's when Michael Jordan decided he wanted to be a major league baseball player.  At that time Michael was regarded as one of if not the best athlete in the world leading the Chicago Bulls to multiple championships while making his opponents look like playground pickup players.  How did he do?  He couldn't even compete at the AA level. Shoot a 25 J with pressure?  All the time.  Hit a 300 yard drive down the middle?  Still does.  Hit .250 in AA ball?  Strike 3.  This question was answered long ago.

            And yes autoracing is a sport.  You've obviously never driven a car on a closed track at 170 mph or crewed in the pits getting a car in and out with fuel and 4 in 12.4 seconds.

            {"commentId":10481952,"threadId":"679137","contentId":"3273462","authorDomain":"jls98001"}
            • 2 votes
            #1.5 - Wed Nov 4, 2009 7:36 PM EST
            {"commentId":10482068,"authorDomain":"triberules"}

            I've also been involved in the debate of whether racing is a sport and I have noticed one prevailing rule that I have yet to find an exception: Those who say it isn't a sport have never been successful in a race car, and those that have been successful agree that is is not only a sport but is one of the hardest to succeed in.

            Also, to say it isn't a sport is disregarding the definition found in any reputable dictionary. Nothing like people who make up their own definitions because they don't like the prevailing and accepted one....lol!

            {"commentId":10482068,"threadId":"679137","contentId":"3273462","authorDomain":"triberules"}
            • 1 vote
            #1.6 - Wed Nov 4, 2009 7:42 PM EST
            {"commentId":10943279,"authorDomain":"kshark"}

            What everyone makes fun of, but frankly having tried it a long time ago, synchronized swimming.

            Try holding your breath that long, not to mention making perfect movements, no equipment, cannot touch the ground period, you have each other, your hands, and legs to stay afloat and to do each movement perfectly. Imagine, seriously, how they accomplish hurling someone through the air, just by floating in the middle of the water column, no ground touching, and able to somehow have the muscles strong enough to toss them.

            But well everyone makes fun of the sport, until they try it.

            A little taste, the Brazilian team from the 2007 FINA championships. I sure as hell cannot do anything like this, and I have been swimming my whole life. If anyone things this is easy, GO try it.

            {"commentId":10943279,"threadId":"679137","contentId":"3273462","authorDomain":"kshark"}
            • 1 vote
            #1.7 - Sun Nov 29, 2009 6:11 PM EST
            Reply
            {"commentId":10310493,"authorDomain":"materialman-1"}

            If it ain't the hardest, it's pretty close.

            {"commentId":10310493,"threadId":"679137","contentId":"3273462","authorDomain":"materialman-1"}
            • 1 vote
            Reply#2 - Tue Oct 27, 2009 11:09 AM EDT
            {"commentId":10318668,"authorDomain":"poopiebear"}

            Baseball - round ball - round bat. end of story

            {"commentId":10318668,"threadId":"679137","contentId":"3273462","authorDomain":"poopiebear"}
            • 4 votes
            Reply#3 - Tue Oct 27, 2009 4:07 PM EDT
            {"commentId":10319631,"authorDomain":"mikethegreat"}

            When you take all the skills required of all players in baseball.....hitting, running, catching, throwing, sliding, bunting, etc. there is no sport that even comes close. Then you take a 162 or more games a season, it is also the most physically demanding.

            {"commentId":10319631,"threadId":"679137","contentId":"3273462","authorDomain":"mikethegreat"}
            • 2 votes
            Reply#4 - Tue Oct 27, 2009 4:45 PM EDT
            {"commentId":10350945,"authorDomain":"lrg51"}

            Uh... No way. Answers like this only come from single sport or fanatic fans. Wrong... try hockey sometime. First... lace on those skates and fall on your arse a few times till you get the hang on the play surface. Then learn to skate, shoot, pass and develop the body control skills for checking. Baseball? ... sheesh! I always thought it was a great sport to play because almost everyone can play at picnics, sandlots, etc...

            {"commentId":10350945,"threadId":"679137","contentId":"3273462","authorDomain":"lrg51"}
              #4.1 - Thu Oct 29, 2009 7:38 AM EDT
              {"commentId":10374754,"authorDomain":"bencas4"}

              LG--you are really silly. We have played hockey in front of our house in the street, were we the equivalent to the elite hockey players ? We have played it on ice---with our friends. Will you see us competing for the Stanley Cup? The baseball we are talking about is at the elite level, not your coveted picnic level. Try hitting a cutter coming at you around 90mph. That is what the elite players from age 16 on up do on a regular basis. That is if you know what a cutter is....

              To hit a baseball, not only do you use a round surface to hit a round ball, but you have to overcome the diversity of what pitch is being thrown. You need to recognize upon the release from the pitcher's hand how he is holding the ball, with how many fingers and where they are placed on the ball. This is only revealed upon his release as most keep their throwing hand in the glove to hide the pitch. When the ball arrives at the plate, it may dip or curve downward. It may suddenly dip or slide. It may curve in from the outside or inside--or be a cutter. After throwing numerous balls at 88-95mph, the pitcher may throw one at 80mph-change up. This destroys any timing that may have developed when the batter watched the pitcher. This is all done within a miniscule of time.

              Get away from the picnic or sandlot and talk about the game we are discussing!

              {"commentId":10374754,"threadId":"679137","contentId":"3273462","authorDomain":"bencas4"}
              • 1 vote
              #4.2 - Fri Oct 30, 2009 11:15 AM EDT
              Reply
              {"commentId":10326809,"authorDomain":"bferrario"}

              George!

              How can you even compare soccer to hitting a big league pitch? All you have to do in soccer is run up and down the field and take a wild kick at a very large ball occasionally. A big league pitch comes at least 90 MPH from 60 feet (.45 of a second), and the darn thing doesn't even go straight! You then have to hit it with a round bat.

              Grow up and realize that soccer was introduced in this country to give a sport to kids who had no other athletic talent, except for being able to run in randem directions for a long time.

              Number two is either hitting a golf ball where you want it to go or the goalie's job.

              {"commentId":10326809,"threadId":"679137","contentId":"3273462","authorDomain":"bferrario"}
              • 1 vote
              Reply#5 - Tue Oct 27, 2009 11:49 PM EDT
              {"commentId":10333387,"authorDomain":"george-3246"}

              Thanks for fulfilling my prophecy, Bruce, with your idiotic "run up and down.....wild kick" comment. After nearly forty years of recreation and sports management experience, I have more knowledge of sports in one of my pube hairs than you have in your whole body.

              Your comment about soccer being "introduced" to give a sport to kids with no other athletic talent except to run in "randem" directions further proves my point. It's "random', you dolt and it only shows your ignorance and probable inability to run 100 yards at any speed.

              {"commentId":10333387,"threadId":"679137","contentId":"3273462","authorDomain":"george-3246"}
                #5.1 - Wed Oct 28, 2009 11:44 AM EDT
                {"commentId":10340153,"authorDomain":"kmar9701"}

                George,

                I agree with your contention that soccer is more challenging than simply running up and down the field and kicking randomly at a large ball. I believe though that the question that was asked was specifically about skills. There is not a single individual skill in soccer that is more difficult than any of the others listed.

                I also see that your 40 years of recreation and sports management experience have made it ok for you to anonymously make arrogant and insulting comments simply because you obviously know better than everyone else. You may want to put that soccer ball down and work on your sportsmanship.

                {"commentId":10340153,"threadId":"679137","contentId":"3273462","authorDomain":"kmar9701"}
                • 2 votes
                #5.2 - Wed Oct 28, 2009 3:50 PM EDT
                Reply
                {"commentId":10328218,"authorDomain":"coloradobubbie"}

                i think all of those things are difficult to do, but the most difficult thing to do that i see in society today is good sportsmanship.

                i voted for play quarterback tho....

                cheers!

                {"commentId":10328218,"threadId":"679137","contentId":"3273462","authorDomain":"coloradobubbie"}
                • 1 vote
                Reply#6 - Wed Oct 28, 2009 3:20 AM EDT
                {"commentId":10338430,"authorDomain":"Tomorrowssoldier"}

                hitting a baseball is easier then hitting a puck out of mid air. Hockey is the hardest sport to play on earth.

                It has everything all the other sports have and then you play it on a 1/2 inch blade on ice.

                {"commentId":10338430,"threadId":"679137","contentId":"3273462","authorDomain":"Tomorrowssoldier"}
                  Reply#7 - Wed Oct 28, 2009 2:52 PM EDT
                  {"commentId":10374907,"authorDomain":"bencas4"}

                  Perhaps it is the hardest for yourself. My son has friends that are elite hockey players. My son was able to participate in their sport yet, they were unable to hit the baseball. Why is that? They excelled at their sport--scholarship material, but they could not step into the batter's box the way the baseball player could pick up a hockey stick and hit the puck. hmmmm

                  {"commentId":10374907,"threadId":"679137","contentId":"3273462","authorDomain":"bencas4"}
                  • 2 votes
                  #7.1 - Fri Oct 30, 2009 11:20 AM EDT
                  Reply
                  {"commentId":10338495,"authorDomain":"scottscotts"}

                  George is an idiot. After 40 years of rec experience you still think that kicking a soccer ball is worthy of inclusion in a discussion about challenging sports. Soccer is meant to give kids a way to pass time when there is nothing else to do.

                  Let us know when you've stood up and tried to hit a fastball. I just kicked a soccer ball with the kids on Saturday. Didn't seem too hard for me.

                  {"commentId":10338495,"threadId":"679137","contentId":"3273462","authorDomain":"scottscotts"}
                  • 3 votes
                  Reply#8 - Wed Oct 28, 2009 2:54 PM EDT
                  {"commentId":10342655,"authorDomain":"george-3246"}

                  Back at you, Scott. How many different sports have you played? You aren't even smart enough to read my first comment that didn't say kicking was the skill. Try running 5 or 6 miles before stopping (trapping) the ball kicked on the fly from 30 or 40 yards away off your chest and then kick it with either foot.

                  Since your effort to kick a ball with the kids didn't seem hard, probably meant you never moved your fat ass more than a few yards. I'd love to see soccer haters like you to try basic soccer skills like dribbling or trapping a passed ball with your feet or legs after running for a while. Everyone watching will know who the idiot is.

                  As a young man, I never had a problem hitting fastball, curve or whatever. The only challenge baseball ever presented to me was not falling asleep in the field waiting for something to happen. BORING! And regardless of what Anyone says, conditioning and sports are like bread and butter. Pitchers & catchers do all the hard work.

                  My favorite sports were wrestling and rugby, a sport that soccer led me in to that I played into my thirties which is only played by real men and, now, women. But over the years, I have played more than twenty sports. Hockey wasn't one of them, but I respect it.

                  If my college would have had a gymnastics program, I could have competed in that as well. No hand out is right, any number of gymnastic skills surpass this bogus list. And don't forget surfing, big ramp skateboarding and the other extreme sports.

                  It's been fun squelching dreams of you couch potatoes with limited sports knowhow.

                  {"commentId":10342655,"threadId":"679137","contentId":"3273462","authorDomain":"george-3246"}
                    #8.1 - Wed Oct 28, 2009 5:07 PM EDT
                    Reply
                    {"commentId":10339187,"authorDomain":"blueherring2006"}

                    Gymnastics...hands down. There is no sport more challenging. These other are just kiddie games hitting balls.

                    {"commentId":10339187,"threadId":"679137","contentId":"3273462","authorDomain":"blueherring2006"}
                      Reply#9 - Wed Oct 28, 2009 3:19 PM EDT
                      {"commentId":10943303,"authorDomain":"kshark"}

                      Oh trust me synchronized swimming I would say is level with gymnastics, and maybe surpasses.

                      {"commentId":10943303,"threadId":"679137","contentId":"3273462","authorDomain":"kshark"}
                        #9.1 - Sun Nov 29, 2009 6:13 PM EST
                        Reply
                        {"commentId":10339803,"authorDomain":"kmar9701"}

                        I think you gymnastics people have this right. Of the items listed, sure hitting a baseball is probably the hardest. Personally I think that doing an arial somersault on a 4 inch wide board 4 feet off the ground. At least you can see the baseball coming the whole time.

                        {"commentId":10339803,"threadId":"679137","contentId":"3273462","authorDomain":"kmar9701"}
                          Reply#10 - Wed Oct 28, 2009 3:40 PM EDT
                          {"commentId":10374948,"authorDomain":"bencas4"}

                          Gymnastics is interesting in that is also requires that participant to be well rounded and multi faceted.

                          {"commentId":10374948,"threadId":"679137","contentId":"3273462","authorDomain":"bencas4"}
                            #10.1 - Fri Oct 30, 2009 11:22 AM EDT
                            Reply
                            {"commentId":10341185,"authorDomain":"LukeKnows"}

                            The first thing that must be done to answer this question is to qualify what we mean when we say "hardest thing to do" in "sports". This means we need two definitions. By hardest we may be talking about the most physically demanding, or that which requires the highest degree of coordination of a complex skill set or any other number of definitions. I like using a simpler approach which is simply numerical. The fewer number of people who can achieve a certain act the harder that act is to do. In politics the hardest thing to do is become president. In business it is being the richest business man (or woman).

                            The second definition requires that we qualify what we mean by sports. Some of you would argue only highly athletic persuits are sports. Others would say that any persuit that has as its goal winning is a sport. For me, both elements are wrong standing alone, as big game hunting and fishing are definitely sports. I like the idea that any activity done for simply for the joy of competing is a sport. Many will argue with this definition, which I think proves that there is no commonly accepted definition of what constitutes a sport. However if we combine the three elements, athletics, winning, and joy of competition I think we have a fairly large consensus of people who would concur with that defintion.

                            Having said all of this, the hardest thing to do in all of sports is to climb to the top of Mount Everest from Base Camp in 21 hours. The athleticism, mental toughness, focus, concentration, and endurance required for this feat is beyond anything most modern athletes could even consider. Only one person in the history of the world has done this, although thousands of well trained and conditioned athletes have tried. There is possibly no one on the earth who could do that today. It is a sport feat of monumental proportion that will probably never be repeated.

                            Luke Knows

                            {"commentId":10341185,"threadId":"679137","contentId":"3273462","authorDomain":"LukeKnows"}
                              Reply#11 - Wed Oct 28, 2009 4:22 PM EDT
                              {"commentId":10343246,"authorDomain":"playsoccer"}

                              Chiri once spent 21 hours at the top of Everest - but the fastest of his ten climbs was just under 17 hours. The apparent current record is just over 8 hours.

                              {"commentId":10343246,"threadId":"679137","contentId":"3273462","authorDomain":"playsoccer"}
                                Reply#12 - Wed Oct 28, 2009 5:31 PM EDT
                                {"commentId":10349289,"authorDomain":"eclectos1"}

                                I think the thing that makes hitting a baseball so hard is that, as was said in the article, it requires analyzing a 90mph spinning incoming projectile less than 3 inches in diameter in less than half a second, deciding what to do about it and then hitting it (or leaving it alone) in such a way that it advances the game, all of this in less than half a second. To make it a little harder, if you hit it less than half an inch off the center of the bat, it will not co-operate in the least. Also, the best do not succeed anything like 4 out of 10 times. I don't know the numbers but I expect that the average at-bat sees the batter face at least 4 or 5 balls which reduces a .400 hitter to only 1 hit out of 10 pitches or less. After baseball, I'd put professional cricket, jai alai and tennis pretty high up the list - all involve a single hitter returning 90+mph balls into a defended area. Hockey has the complication that the hitter is moving quickly and is surrounded by other players but also has the advantage that the hitter is not alone (as with any other team v. team sport).

                                Hitting a golf ball which is sitting still on the ground seems a little easier - especially when you consider how many professional and amateur golfers make par regularly. Indeed, any golfer who averaged 730 on an 18-hole course (1 in 10 shots working out), would not last long.

                                One last comment - how many ex-college baseball and even AAA players admit that the reason they couldn't go any further was because they couldn't hit a curve ball.

                                {"commentId":10349289,"threadId":"679137","contentId":"3273462","authorDomain":"eclectos1"}
                                • 1 vote
                                Reply#13 - Thu Oct 29, 2009 12:39 AM EDT
                                {"commentId":10351055,"authorDomain":"lrg51"}

                                I have trouble with the hockey logic or any team logic... because it doesn't make sense by comparison. What does more players have to do with a single player hitting a baseball... when the entire configuration and strategy of the game is so different? I thought we were comparing player skills and not team sports. I didn't think we were comparing hitting success with the single skill of hitting a ball.

                                {"commentId":10351055,"threadId":"679137","contentId":"3273462","authorDomain":"lrg51"}
                                • 1 vote
                                #13.1 - Thu Oct 29, 2009 7:52 AM EDT
                                Reply
                                {"commentId":10350030,"authorDomain":"rockyrv"}

                                I was a pretty fair hitter in high school but once, when in Chicago for a Cubs game a bunch of us went to Sluggers, a local sports bar, after the game to try out the batting cages upstairs. In the 70 mph cage I got some decent wood on the ball, in the 80 mph cage a couple of fouls and in the 90+ mph cage no contact at all, and I knew what was coming! Yes, without a doubt, hitting a pitched ball with a round bat is the hardest thing to do in sports. Just ask Michael Jordon!

                                {"commentId":10350030,"threadId":"679137","contentId":"3273462","authorDomain":"rockyrv"}
                                • 1 vote
                                Reply#14 - Thu Oct 29, 2009 2:37 AM EDT
                                {"commentId":10355769,"authorDomain":"2scoops"}

                                Wow George, you're such a hypocrite. First you "prophecise" that everyone will claim soccer is a boring sport and then you turn around and call baseball BORING! Baseball is a thinking mans game, and you've proven that you are simple minded.

                                Let's compare apples and oranges: I have played both sports at many levels, but if I spent 1 year training in only soccer skills, I'm confident I would be a skillful soccer player. If I also spent 1 year training in only hitting a baseball "skillfully", I wouldn't even make single A ball.

                                {"commentId":10355769,"threadId":"679137","contentId":"3273462","authorDomain":"2scoops"}
                                • 1 vote
                                Reply#15 - Thu Oct 29, 2009 12:16 PM EDT
                                {"commentId":10363837,"authorDomain":"historydave"}

                                Oh nonsense.

                                Batting averages don't measure how often someone hits the ball - they measure how often someone hits the ball AND reaches base safely. So telling me that the best players can only hit the ball 4 out of 10 times is pure horse waste. An AVERAGE professional baseball player can hit two out of every three pitches he swings at, even if most of those are foul balls or outs. Hitting the ball isn't the problem. Reaching base is.

                                But try to put a puck past an NHL goalie. Those guys stop 90% of what they see. If your scoring success is 15%, you're a hero.

                                {"commentId":10363837,"threadId":"679137","contentId":"3273462","authorDomain":"historydave"}
                                  Reply#16 - Thu Oct 29, 2009 5:42 PM EDT
                                  {"commentId":10370866,"authorDomain":"earthworx"}

                                  I think it's much harder to hit a good golf shot than a baseball. In golf you swing a club approximately 35 feet to hit a less than 1 square inch target with a less than 1 square inch hitting surface. That said, is hitting a baseball tougher than pole vaulting? How about gymnastics? Diving? Figure skating? It's a difficult thing to quantify.

                                  {"commentId":10370866,"threadId":"679137","contentId":"3273462","authorDomain":"earthworx"}
                                    Reply#17 - Fri Oct 30, 2009 6:54 AM EDT
                                    {"commentId":10373741,"authorDomain":"lawrencereed"}

                                    How about returning a serve in tennis? They come as fast as 145 miles per hour, can come at wider angles, and can be either to a forehand or a backhand.

                                    Also, having a round bat is an advantage. In tennis, if your angle is off, your return is off.

                                    {"commentId":10373741,"threadId":"679137","contentId":"3273462","authorDomain":"lawrencereed"}
                                    • 1 vote
                                    Reply#18 - Fri Oct 30, 2009 10:35 AM EDT
                                    {"commentId":10405560,"authorDomain":"racingdan11"}

                                    The responses here are, by definition, truly Subjective.

                                    ... Have an imagination and openness.

                                    Hitting a 200 yard GOLF Shot to a pin within 2 feet would qualify as EXTREMELY DIFFICULT. A "better than average" golfer may attain this excellence about as frequently as a hole-in-one.

                                    HAVE A GREAT DAY, SPORTSMEN (WOMEN) !

                                    {"commentId":10405560,"threadId":"679137","contentId":"3273462","authorDomain":"racingdan11"}
                                    • 1 vote
                                    Reply#19 - Sun Nov 1, 2009 6:05 AM EST
                                    {"commentId":10405779,"authorDomain":"albruno"}

                                    Wonder how many athletes cross train or for that matter find what they do naturally challenging or downright impossible to master

                                    ex.. baseball player golfing.. or on skates stopping a puck
                                    or golfer smashing a baseball?

                                    it is natural to some and toughest to those untrained..

                                    i cannot hula-hoop to me that is the toughest!

                                    but i can hit a golfball and baseball (enough to look ok)

                                    {"commentId":10405779,"threadId":"679137","contentId":"3273462","authorDomain":"albruno"}
                                    • 1 vote
                                    Reply#20 - Sun Nov 1, 2009 7:22 AM EST
                                    Jump to discussion page: 1 2
                                    {"canLink":false,"threadId":"679137","isPrivate":false}
                                    Leave a Comment:
                                    You're in Easy Mode. If you prefer, you can use XHTML Mode instead.
                                    As a new user, you may notice a few temporary content restrictions. Click here for more info.